Do-It-Yourself Water Filtration

Posted by By Darrell Nicholson at 12:33PM - Comments: (3)

June 4, 2013

One of the first things that you realize after a few seasons of cruising is that approaches to life aboard vary between two wide extremes: cruisers who by choice or because of a limited budget live with minimal creature comforts, and those cruisers who sacrifice little more than living space when they move aboard.

You’d think that when it came to basic essentials like food and water, there would be some overlap between these two groups, but that isn’t necessarily the case. Take water, for example.

During his circumnavigation, Practical Sailor editor-at-large Nick Nicholson (no relation) installed a General Ecology Seagull IV filter, an expensive solution, but one he felt was worth it. My wife and I, meanwhile, used local water where we roamed, which included some remote areas of South America, the Pacific, and Southeast Asia, with little or no treatment during most of our 10 years of living aboard.

In the few areas where water seemed sketchy, we followed Lin and Larry Pardey’s general guidelines in their book “The Care and Feeding of the Offshore Crew” for chlorine treatment. We would treat the water in jerry jugs before pouring it into our tanks. As I recall, that practice only lasted about a year, when we noticed that many of the locals seemed a lot healthier than the folks back home, and our concerns about drinking the local water was replaced by tropical languor.

Nick reported that most cruising boats he met during his first year of tropical cruising had some type of watermaker, but usually chose to take advantage of the local water supply when dockside or anchored in polluted harbors. When we were cruising abroad in the early ’90s, it seemed that less than half the boats we met regularly used watermakers.

The Nitty Gritty

All shore-sourced water supplies, either in the U.S. or overseas, contain particulate matter. This may be pipe scale, sand, small bits of grass, or other types of sediment. While not necessarily harmful, sediment builds up in your boat’s plumbing. It can settle in the bottom of tanks, only to get stirred up during an offshore passage. Over time, it can wreak havoc with water pumps, destroy ceramic water fixture cartridges, and prevent the seating of rubber faucet washers.

Nick learned this the hard way when his Grohe faucets started leaking after two years. Fortunately, replacing the cartridges was easy—once he found them—but after that experience, he became determined to reduce sediment in the entire water system.

My wife and I had no problems with sediment fouling our pumps, probably because we relied solely on forgiving diaphragm foot pumps from Whale. We went through three foot-pumps in 10 years, but that was because plastic housings cracked through hard use, not because of sediment. We did flush out our tanks pretty regularly when the water was looking more soupy than usual. I don’t necessarily condone our approach. I felt we were careful enough, and it was simply what we did—another data point to consider, so to speak. I suspect Nick might have the last laugh when doctors discover some sort of parasite consuming my innards, but so far my wife and I are doing just fine in spite of our relatively lackadaisical approach to water (knock on wood).

Protecting Your Water Pumps

If you do have a more sensitive impellor-type pump on your boat, protection is relatively simple. Just install an in-line sediment strainer just upstream from your freshwater pressure pump. Nick used a Par Pumpgard filter, positioned to be easily accessible for routine checking and cleaning. This is a compact, small-capacity stainless-steel mesh strainer in a clear plastic housing. Most of the toilets in our recent toilet test came with these filters, as safeguards against pump damage. They are relatively cheap—about $20 at any marine store.

A Simple Pre-Filter

In Grenada, Nick ran into a couple on a well-equipped Baba 35 who pre-filtered shore water before it even got to the boat, and he later adopted that approach. On a trip back to the States, he picked up a $20 Omni filter housing at a home supply store. GE makes a similar one, as well. The one Nick bought uses standard 9.5-inch filter elements, which he found available worldwide. For a few dollars more, you can get a clear filter housing that allows you to monitor the state of the filter element more easily.

The rest of his custom pre-filter system comprised two plastic hose nipples screwed into the filter housing, a pair of hose clamps, 4 feet of .75-inch reinforced PVC water hose, and a couple of plastic garden hose end fittings. To use the simple in-line filter, Nick would screw the filter inlet hose to the shoreside water bib, then couple the boat’s water hose to the filter’s outlet.

Total cost of this handy gadget today is about $45, including a couple of spare 30-micron sediment filter cartridges. Flow rate through the filter is about four gallons per minute, so it provides minimal increase in your watering time.

Serious Filtration

All the drinking water aboard Nick’s Calypso, even the water they made themselves, went through a General Ecology Seagull IV purification system. This expensive filtering system—list price is over $700—will remove just about everything harmful from water, according to the manufacturer. Any water considered “bacteriologically acceptable for treatment” by the U.S. Public Health Service standards can be rendered safe by the Seagull IV.

The components of the Seagull IV model X-IF—the most common version seen aboard boats—are a compact stainless-steel filter housing with bulkhead mounting bracket, a nice sink-mounted faucet, plus the appropriate hookup hardware. You also get one filter element, which is good for about a year. Spare filter elements are not cheap at about $90 each. Nick mounted the filter housing under the galley sink and plumbed the filter straight into the pressurized side of our freshwater system through a T-fitting. An in-line shutoff valve upstream of the filter makes it possible to change filter elements without shutting down and draining the water system.

Even today, when I can better afford Nick’s approach, it seems a little expensive. I wouldn’t call it overkill, especially now that I have a greater appreciation of the importance of good health, but I suspect there are some more affordable options out there that are just as effective.

If you have some inexpensive water treatment systems to share, please include them in the comments below. In the meantime, we’re rounding up some new products from General Ecology (makers of the popular Seagull IV treatment device) and other makers to see if we can hunt down any bargains. The growing popularity of portable ultraviolet systems seems to offer some new avenues that we’ll be exploring as well.

It’s my feeling that there are probably a number of home-purifying systems that would be readily adaptable to a boat at less expense. If you know of a sensible water treatment product for us to look at, let us know below in the comments section or by emailing me at practicalsailor@belvoirpubs.com.

Comments (3)

On "Tribute" we've had great luck with a PUR faucet mounted filter. It snaps onto an ordinary faucet and the top of the line model removes almost every kind of contaminant. It is available in big box stores and hardware stores as are the refill cartridges. I've seen the cartridges on line for as low as 6 for $59. Each cartridge filters 100 gallons.

We carry 200 gallons of water on board in two 100 gallon tanks. We can go up to 6 weeks between fill ups. We also have left water on board for as long as 4 months and after filtration it still tastes fine.

For extra freshness we filter the water a second time through a Brita filter but that's really overkill. However, it makes my wife happy.

Jack Dexter S/V "Tribute"

Posted by: Tribute | June 6, 2013 9:09 AM    Report this comment

In 2010, after a fair amount of reserach, I installed the 3M Marine Wvb3 3.5 Gpm Water Filter Kit in-line between my water pump and my water heater and water distribution system. For about $250 from Amazon, the unit is easy to install and provides 15,000 gallons of clean water. 3M claims that it removes 99.9% of bacteria, parasitic cysts, algae and mold spores and removes +95% of chlorine. You can check out the product at http://multimedia.3m.com/mws/mediawebserver?66666UuZjcFSLXTtmxTcOxTXEVuQEcuZgVs6EVs6E666666--.

My reason for installing it before the water heater was to minimize rapid contamination of the unit.

I have lived aboard in the eastern caribbean for most of the 3 years since it was installed and I am very statisfied. Given the variable water quality in the Caribbean, I continue to chlorinate my water and to flush my 100 gallon water tank at once a season.

Norman, Orizzonti Sereni

Posted by: Norman P | June 5, 2013 2:11 PM    Report this comment

A cheap but useful solution can be bought at WalMart in the RV section. It's an in-line filter with garden hose threads on both ends. Every water fill-up I just attach it to the end of my hose so that I at least have relatively clean and sediment free water going in the tanks. They are approximately 3" diameter by 10" long so they're easy to store.

Posted by: David C | June 5, 2013 11:30 AM    Report this comment


Add your comments ...

New to Practical Sailor? Register for Free!

Already Registered? Log in

Forgot your password? Click Here.