Features July 2007 Issue

Practical Sailor Gets a Grip on Women’s Boat Shoes

Like Cinderellas of the yacht club, testers donned a slew of women’s sailing shoes from top manufacturers and put them to the test in real-world settings. Performance footwear from makers including Helly Hansen, Harken, Teva, Sebago, Sperry, and Slam, were evaluated for grip, foot protection, comfort, and odor resistance. To find out which is the best sailing shoe where grip is concerned, Practical Sailor tested them on wet and dry teak and nonskid.

Often times in the personal sailing gear arena, women sailors are left with limited choices&emdash;inflatable life vests and foul weather bibs come to mind. However, when it comes to boat shoes, the selection is endless for both the racer and the cruiser. We tested 13 pairs of performance sailing shoes from the most popular manufacturers. Granted racers and cruisers won’t necessarily be looking for the same thing out of a shoe, but we found comfort, grip, and foot protection are key for any footwear to be worn aboard.

                                                     ****

Women's Boat Shoes
Testers tried out 13 pairs of athletic-style boat shoes for women. We narrowed the field to six favorites: Trimmer and Valencia by Harken, Hydro Power and Hydrator W2 Breathe by Helly Hansen, Teva’s Atrato, and Sperry’s Figawi2.

Often times in the personal sailing gear arena, women sailors are left with limited choices&emdash;inflatable PFDs and foul weather bibs come to mind. However, when it comes to boat shoes, the selection is endless for both the racer and the cruiser. The styles and colors run the gamut from gray running shoe to pink water moccasin to metallic Mary Jane.

On the heels of our men’s sailing shoes review (June 2007), we tested 13 pairs of women’s boat shoes. Obviously, we couldn’t test all those on the market, but the shoes we tested represent a good cross-section of what is available from the top brands.

We looked at shoes from marine hardware and apparel manufacturer Harken Yacht Equipment; Norwegian safety and sailing gear manufacturer Helly Hansen; shoe giant Sebago; well-known boat-shoe-maker Sperry Top-Sider; Italian sportswear maker Slam; and outdoor apparel manufacturer Teva. We tested all 13 pairs according to the same protocol (see "Getting a Grip,") and then picked our top performers to review.

Harken Trimmer

This running-shoe-style product was designed by Harken and made by Saucony, a company well-known for its athletic shoes. At press time, the Trimmer had been discontinued but was still available through some chandleries and online footwear stores. (We found it for as low as $25 at

www.team1newport.com.)

The Trimmer has the grip and breathability of a boat shoe with the heel and arch support of a running shoe. It has a synthetic leather and multi-layer mesh upper, which aids air circulation, keeping feet drier and cooler. The Trimmer also has an ethylene vinyl acetate (EVA) midsole that helps cushion impact to the knees and back, as well as anti-bacterial, silver threads woven into the footbed to reduce odor.

Harken’s non-marking sole utilizes a multi-directional siping, which offers excellent traction. Overall, the Trimmer outperformed all other shoes in our grip test. It has good foot protection around the toe and other areas likely to take a beating. Testers also like the shoe’s laces. The thick, flat, cotton cord were easy to grip and tie whether it was wet or dry.

Its only drawback was its drainage system. After being submerged, the Trimmer&emdash;the second lightest shoe in the test, behind the Tevas&emdash;held a fair amount of water (3.5 ounces).

Bottom Line:

Testers were disappointed to learn this shoe has been discontinued, as it would have been the top pick otherwise. It outperformed the other shoes in most categories, although we’d prefer a better drainage system. If you can find a pair&emdash;particularly one priced as low as we found it&emdash;we recommend snatching them up. The Trimmer is a great shoe, and at $25, it’s our Budget Buy.

Harken Trimmer
Harken Trimmer

 

Harken Valencia

The Valencia’s Euro-styling is much like the suede bowling shoes of yesteryear. Testers were skeptical that suede would prove an appropriate material for a boat shoe constantly subjected to wet conditions. However, we were pleasantly surprised to find that the Valencia’s treated suede upper readily repels sea spray and light showers. It doesn’t do as well when it’s submerged: The 10-ounce Valencia rated in the middle of the pack during the drainage test, retaining 2.7 ounces of water. But when you consider that it’s a real-leather shoe being compared to shoes made of synthetic materials, its performance wasn’t too shabby.

Harken Valencia
Harken Valencia

The upper combines the waterproofed suede with breathable mesh. Testers found breathability sufficient during the Florida springtime; however, we expect the Valencia would be too warm for tropical duty.

The Valencia has the same EVA midsole and silver-threaded footbed as the Trimmer. It also has very good grip but accomplishes it through 360-degree radial siping at the foot’s three major pressure zones. It lacks the stability of the Trimmer’s wide toe box, however, and so had lower grip test numbers. The Valencia’s great ankle and arch support offer a feeling of secure footing.

Bottom Line:

The Valencia offers top-notch support, grip, and odor protection. Testers’ main concern is water retention. It’s a quality-made shoe, and we recommend it for use in cooler climates.

Helly Hansen
Hydrator W2 Breathe

The Helly Hansen line of women’s boating shoes&emdash;much like the line of men’s shoe we detailed in the June issue&emdash;has very unique styling. For the most part, the look did not fit testers’ tastes. However, the Hydrator W2 Breathe grew on us. After wearing the shoe in a few regattas and walking around, testers found it comfortable and airy with good drainage. The synthetic leather and mesh upper offers good breathability in even the hottest weather. The shoe sides and lace eyelets feature reflective material that testers figure must be more meant for styling or safety on the street, rather than on the water

The Hydrator Breathe has a removable, perforated EVA midsole that aids in comfort and drainage. It has four, screened "H" cut-outs in the sole sides (two at the inside arch and two on the outer foot) where the water exits the shoe. This, along with the perforated midsole, is part of Helly Hansen’s W2 (Water In, Water Out) system.

Helly Hansen Hyrdator W2 Breathe
Helly Hansen Hyrdator W2 Breathe

Another characteristic indicative of the Helly line is good foot protection. Added rubber at the toe and heel protect the most abused areas.

The Hydrator Breathe rated Good in our grip test. Helly Hansen calls the tread system "Storm Grip," a gum rubber outsole with siped panels at the main pressure points.

One issue we encountered was availability. We had a hard time finding the shoes, and they’re not listed on the Helly website.

Bottom Line:

These are great warm weather shoes. They’re not cheap, but if you’re willing to spend a little more for a well-made, well-designed shoe, we recommend them.

Helly Hansen Hydro Power W

The Hydro Power’s design and performance are quite similar to the Hydrator Breathe’s. It too has a vinyl and mesh upper for good breathability and a removable, perforated EVA midsole. The W2 drainage system was a success in testers’ opinions as both top-performing Helly Hansens retained only about 2 ounces of water after being submerged. (Only the Sperry Figawi2 drained better.)

The Hydro Power is a fusion of water and trail shoe, so it has improved support over the Hydrator. It also has a neoprene, sock-like opening and an updated grip system, dubbed "Ultra Storm Grip," which actually performed worse on the nonskid than the Storm Grip. The sole has varying degrees of siping, concentrated at the ball and heel of the foot.

Helly Hansen Hyrdo Power
Helly Hansen Hyrdo Power

The Hydro Power offers better foot protection than any other shoe tested. It has a large, hard-rubber toe, and the sole lips up over the foot at the heel and other spots.

The shoe’s tongue is mostly mesh and is connected to the shoe on three sides, making it easier to slip on and the tongue less likely to slide around.

Bottom Line:

The Hydro Power has all the great characteristics of the Hydrator Breathe, plus extra foot protection, lower price, and improved design. Its only drawback is its performance on nonskid, so it’s our Practical Sailor Best Choice for use on teak decks.

Sperry Figawi2

The athletic shoe-style Figawi2 features a brushed, waterproofed synthetic leather and layered mesh upper. It has a contoured, foam EVA footbed, which Sperry says promotes water drainage. The shoe also has four screened ports at the upper-rubber sole seam to allow water to exit the shoe. Of the top picks, the Figawi drained the best, retaining only 1.3 ounces of water and keeping the 9.4-ounce shoe lightweight even wet.

The sole incorporates thin, multi-directional siping with separate panels at the ball and heel. Sperry calls the system Quadro Grip, and testers found it performed well.

The rubber sole extends up over the heel about an inch but does not cover the toe, offering better footing but not much protection.

One complaint testers had about the Figawi2 was its cord-style laces, which refused to stay tied.

Sperry Figawi2
Sperry Figawi2

Bottom Line:

The Sperry Figawi2 is a lightweight shoe that is as comfortable after three hours’ standing at the helm as it is in the store. We’d prefer better toe protection, but the efficient drainage system, conservative styling, and unmatched breathability make it more than worth the $80.

Teva Atrato

The Teva Atrato is a comfortable, lightweight, multi-sport shoe with Good foot protection. At 8.2 ounces, it was the lightest shoe in the test. The synthetic leather and fabric-mesh upper also has vents with metal-mesh backing covered with slotted plastic ribs. Testers expected this unique system&emdash;which Teva describes as 360-degree drainability&emdash;to offer better drainage than the other test shoes as it has larger exit ports and a perforated footbed. However, the Atrato retained 2.7 ounces of water after being submerged&emdash;that was more than all of the other top picks except the Harken shoes.

The area around the ankle is lined with neoprene to reduce friction on bare skin. The lacing system is a thin, continuous line of rounded cord that is cinched with a cam slide. The cord ends and slide are secured via a flap at the top of the tongue that snaps closed. This makes donning quicker and easier, and it also keeps the laces from being errantly snagged. The weak link to this setup is the synthetic leather thumb tab at the lace’s end. It’s not rugged, and easily pulled off the laces of one of our test shoes.

Teva Atrato
Teva Atrato

Raised rubber ribs protect the heel, but there is no toe guard. What it lacks in protection, it makes up for in grip. The Atrato’s sole, dubbed "Spider Rubber," provided the second best overall grip of the test shoes and tied for the top performance on nonskid.

Bottom Line:

The Teva offers superb comfort and grip, and better-than-average drainage, all for the lowest price among the top performers, $75. This earns the Atrato the Practical Sailor Best Choice for use on nonskid decks.

Just before presstime, we received a new shoe from Teva, the Sunkosi. At first glance, the Sunkosi looks promising with a thorough drainage system, lightweight construction, and Excellent foot protection. It also has Spider Rubber, so we expect a good showing in the grip test. Stay tuned for a shoe test update.

Also Tested

Below is a brief look at the other shoes we tested. For more information on how these shoes measured up to our top picks, take a look at the Value Guide chart.

• Helly Hansen Latitude 60&emdash; All-leather upper lined with breathable mesh; six medium, metal-screened drainage ports at arch; both upper and metal drains fared poorly in the mildew/corrosion-resistance tests; multi-directional siping; little toe protection; good support; too hot for warm weather use; and drainage problems likely (retained nearly 3 ounces of water after submersion).

Helly Hansen Hydrator Racing W&emdash; Upper is mesh and coated vinyl; excellent drainage and breathability; minimal siping; "Ultra Storm Grip" rubber; testers did not like the very thin cord laces, which cinch with a spring-loaded thumb cam that doesn’t seem rugged enough.

Helly Hansen Vala W&emdash; Water-moccasin-style; mesh and vinyl upper; multi-directional siping; good breathability; for a water moccasin, we’d pick the Helly Water Moc W over these.

Helly Hansen Water Moc W&emdash; Neoprene and mesh upper; water moccasin-style with better (albeit minimal) protection and good traction; same sole as Vala, but performed better in grip test; good drainage; made for getting wet.

• Sebago Wave Ariel&emdash; Mary Jane style; synthetic leather and fabric upper with Velcro closure, breathable mesh trim; EVA midsole; poor ankle support (testers’ ankles rolled during the grip test and regular use); little water retention (1.3 ounces); "Octopod" sole uses suction-cup style tread.

Sebago Wave Extreme&emdash; Mesh upper with Nubuck trim and neoprene collar; insole covered with washable sock (testers found the sock uncomfortable when wet as it tended to bunch under toes); elastic cord laces cinch with thumb cam; antibacterial footbed; Octopod tread.

• Slam Mistral&emdash; Layered mesh upper with suede trim at the sole; adequate breathability, but likely to prove hot in tropical climes; a quality performance shoe held back by poor drainage as neither the midsole or bottom sole have exit ports for water; grip is good; stiff suede trim offers good foot protection.

Conclusion

When it comes to performance footwear on board, look for a comfortable shoe with good grip and good foot protection. Our top picks of the shoes we tested are the Helly Hansen Hydro Power W, the

Practical Sailor Best Choice for teak, and Teva Atrato, the Practical Sailor Best Choice for nonskid.

Comments (0)

Be the first to comment on this post using the section below.

New to Practical Sailor?
Register for Free!

Already Registered?
Log In