Systems & Propulsion
Testers measured gas levels inside the test “holding tanks.” This test tank has the Big Orange vent filter installed in the line.
Holding Tanks: Getting the Stink Out
Practical Sailor tests holding tank vent filters from Big Orange, Vetus, and Dometic, plus one homemade filter.
The quality of onboard living suffers when each flush of the head becomes public knowledge within minutes, and a boat that smells bad won’t be a part of your family for long. Practical Sailor tested three vent filters for holding tanks, from makers Big Orange, Vetus, and Dometic, and tested one homemade vent filter. When sanitary wastes are allowed to biodegrade in a closed tank, particularly with poor mixing and inadequate oxygen, anaerobic bacteria dominate. These bacteria particles can make a boat unpleasant or unlivable unless they are eliminated or contained. Carbon filters are one solution to the odor problem; they are simple, dependable and absorb a wide variety of odors.
More Systems & Propulsion
-
Test Setup Simulates Onboard Sewage System
Subscribers Only — To create a real-world test, we assembled a series of miniature holding tanks containing sanitary waste generously... -
Avoid Plugging with Proper Vent Installation
Subscribers Only — The effectiveness of activated carbon comes both from surface activity (a result of activation by partial combustion... -
On a Side Note: Holding Tanks
Subscribers Only — Although none of the test tanks or the test boat’s holding tank accumulated solids sufficient to restrict... -
Solutions for a Stinky Holding Tank
Subscribers Only — Practical Sailor testers looked at a large field of holding tank additives and found that chemical treatments that... -
Ziggy the Iguana Puts Odor Control to the Test
Subscribers Only — For a real-world test, we created a series of small but real-world holding tanks containing real sanitary waste. The... -
Real-world Advice from Holding Tank Makers
Subscribers Only — Before beginning a series of tests, we always involve the manufacturers. They have a wealth of information they are... -
Marine Holding Tanks Go Head-to-Head
Subscribers Only — In our 2002 holding tank test, SeaLand emerged as the winner. The material of choice for holding tanks continues to... -
Sea Flush Eases Winter Woes
Subscribers Only — For those in colder climes, the only drag bigger than the end of the sailing season is the need to winterize engines,... -
Engine Maintenance: Keeping Your Fuel Clean
Subscribers Only — No good ever comes of fouled diesel fuel. One of the best ways to keep fuel free of contamination issues like... -
Deck Washdown Pumps for Boats
Subscribers Only — Practical Sailor evaluated washdown pumps capable of performing high-pressure cleanup chores on boats ranging in size...
