Making Sense of Our Ratings

Posted by Darrell Nicholson at 11:21PM - Comments: (1)

Practical Sailor Managing Editor Ann Key rates bottom paint panels.

Most long-time readers are familiar with our ratings categories—Best Choice, Recommended, and Budget Buy—but their significance might not be so obvious to new readers. Recently, I’ve received a number of letters from people asking us to clarify what these ratings mean.

Best Choice: Indicated by a single star on the PS Value Guide table that accompanies most test reports (here's an example); this is a product that meets our highest standards regardless of price. Not only does the product outperform competitors in testing, it has the features and robust construction that make it suitable for offshore sailing. Sailors who are pondering a long-term cruise should consider Best Choice products when provisioning, upgrading, or refitting their boat.

Recommended: Indicated by a checkmark on the PS Value Guide table; this product falls short of the Best Choice product in overall testing, but it excels in one or more evaluation points or has special features that might make it the most desirable for certain types of sailors, or for sailors with certain preferences. An example would be an environmentally friendly bottom paint.

Budget Buy: Indicated by a dollar sign on the PS Value Guide; this is the least expensive product in our test that we would not hesitate to recommend to a reader or friend. The Budget Buy products tend to be a better match for coastal or inland sailors than for offshore sailors, but there have been several cases—particularly in the maintenance category—in which the Budget Buy product is also the Best Choice. Because prices change after each issue goes to press, we encourage readers to compare prices before buying.

If you have any questions about our testing program, ratings system, or have suggestions for future tests, let us know, either by e-mail or in the comment box below.

Comments (1)

Wow Darrell,
i am a long time subscriber, and an 8 year live-aboard couple who has cruised continually, but did not realize the Budget Buy was not considered as suitable for offshore sailors as the other categories! Thanks for the update and refresher. We have just completed a semi-circumnavigation touching the shores of 5 continents and 48 countries and treasure the downloads of Practical Sailor for your guidance and evaluations. Ed and Sue Kelly on USSV Angel Louise, now lying St Barth

Posted by: CaptEdKelly | February 13, 2015 11:36 AM    Report this comment

New to Practical Sailor?
Register for Free!

Already Registered?
Log In