A Practical Look at Waxing and Polishing Your Boat

Posted by Darrell Nicholson at 04:06PM - Comments: (5)

May 12, 2015

Without the aid of a power buffer and scaffold, applying some of these waxes can be back-aching work.

With Memorial Day looming, I am plunging once again into polishing and waxing fiberglass boat hulls. This post (which is an update of an extremely popular post from a few years ago) covers almost everything you need to know about cleaning, polishing, and waxing your boat. It includes links to our online "how-to" resources and links to our tests of various classes of products mentioned. The main purpose of the article is to provide an overview of the many archive articles we have in our library on this topic, so that you can choose which reports best apply to your situation and then dig in as deep as you like.

 Most of these articles can be found by using the advanced search function on www.practical-sailor.comor searching using Google and entering "Practical Sailor WAX" or the "Practical Sailor GELCOAT" or "Practical Sailor POLISH." If you're serious about protecting your investment and prefer to have all our research in one, easy-to-access eBook, then check out Marine Cleaners the Complete Series.

There are several ways to attack the buff-and-wax ritual, and I would not say there is one right way for everyone. However, some approaches do get better results than others. I would categorize the types of wax jobs like this:

1) The quick-and-dirty boat wax job, for the full-time cruiser who just wants to protect the boat's gelcoat from further degradation, prevent gelcoat stains, and make boat-cleaning jobs easier.

2) The perfectionist wax job, for the sailor who wants all of the above, plus wants the boat to look its glossy-best.

3) The in-between wax job, for the sailor who wants his boat to look good, but not at the expense of adding an extra day to his haulout or lay-days.

And certainly, the condition of the boat has a big impact on how you approach the project. If you're bringing a boat back from the dead, the quick-and-dirty wax job is not really an option (although some makers of "miracle products" would lead you to think differently). You must be prepared to put in some elbow grease.

No matter which category you are in, your waxing job will have three basic steps:

1) Cleaning: This includes getting rid of salt, dirt, grease, mold, stains. You could break this down into various stages, depending on the condition of the hull, general cleaning and stain removal.

2) Polishing: This creates the smooth glossy surface to be protected. If you have an old hull, there could be several stages to this process. We recently tested a boxful of polishes, and I offered some tips in a recent blog post on polishing.

3) Waxing: This is the application of a thin polymer or natural wax coating to seal and protect your polished gelcoat.

The important thing to remember is that if your hull is not clean before you begin polishing or waxing, you might drive dirt further into the pores of the gelcoat. Not the end of the world, but you won't get the best results.

For general background, I recommend two good reads from our archives. Both are written by Nick Nicholson, a former editor at Practical Sailor, who is now involved in a number of big sailing events, including the America's Cup, the Newport-Bermuda Race, and the Volvo Ocean Race.

For a broad look at how the sun affects plastics and why we should protect our gelcoat, check out

Plastics Versus the Weather: The Nature of Losing Battle

For a gelcoat care overview, read Nick's piece on restoring an old boat. Note that he hand polishes, which I don't recommend for larger boats, particularly if you use one of the harder paste waxes. Most maintenance wax jobs won't need all the steps here:

Offshore Log: Gelcoat Maintenance

I also offered some quick tips to gelcoat repair using a Preval sprayer in a recent blog  post.

Tools

Your biggest investment will be a good polisher. We've looked at various options, ranging from el-cheapos to mid-priced powertools aimed at the automotive market, to higher-end tools geared specifically for use on boats. Lately, for polishing, waxing, and buffing, we've been using a Dewalt variable-speed polisher, the DeWalt DW849, with a 3M 3M-05705 Superbuff Polishing Pad and the 3M-05710 Superbuff Adapter (used to fit pads on any standard 5/8-inch shaft slow-speed polisher).

Two other products worth looking at:

An inexpensive variable speed from Chicago Electric:

This one rattles and and hums, but it works. Ours is still working, but it gets used only twice a year. Harbor Freight also has 7.5-inch wool buffing pads to match for much less than the 3M versions.

There is also a marine-tailored, small-diameter, dual-action polisher from Shurhold.

This one helps avoid swirl marks and is relatively lightweight. It's good for micro-finishing.

The Shurhold buffer has dual action to prevent swirl marks.

It has some nice features (like a built-in breaker, in case there is a fault in the circuit), and is sized to take the smaller 3M Finesse-It pads that 3M recommend for the Finesse It step below. Shurhold also makes its own buffing compound, Buff-Magic.

I covered tools in a little more detail in my fairly recent blog post on polishing.

Machine Technique

I generally apply the compound and wax by hand, using a basic microfiber round waxing pad. I then use the Dewalt to compound and remove wax. The key is to go very light at a low-RPM. I often will buff again with one of those really soft "lambswool" buffing pads, or a microfiber cloth by hand. Good polishing products will designate the RPM-range that is suitable. Start at the low end of that range. Local boat maintenance guru Nelson Roberts shared his polishing techniques with us in a recent blog post "Buff Your Hull Like a Pro."

General Cleaning

Wash thoroughly, removing all oil and grease. Our recent test of boat soaps found some clear winners, including some evironmentally friendly products that can be safely used on boats in the water. Keep in mind, however, that if you DO want to get rid of your old wax, many boat soaps are mildly formulated so they will NOT remove waxes. For this stage of cleaning, Nick likes Simple Green—which does remove the wax. He dilutes as needed. You could do the same with one of the recommended cleaners below in our multipurpose cleaner test, which includes some eco-friendly choices.

For serious stains, spray your chosen cleaner undiluted. Note that ALL of the spray cleaners in our last multipurpose cleaner test removed wax.

For mildew, chlorine is the ticket. Outdoor Clorox works well. You can also try some of the best products in our last mildew cleaner test, which included some more eco-friendly solutions.

If grease or exhaust soot is the big problem, then a degreaser will also work.

Serious Hull Stains

Mild acids are very effective at attacking serious stains that don't respond to the above treatments. Used incorrectly or in strong concentrations, acid cleaners can harm gelcoat, so use it sparingly and follow directions. Do a test patch first, and be sure to rinse thoroughly. Also, be sure to cover a trailer well as it will take galvanizing and even paint off. Keep away from paint and varnish. Clearly, it is better to do all of your hull cleaning before painting the bottom.

Nick liked the Davis FSR gel, here's our complete report on on 22 different hull-stain cleaners.

For a softer, more eco-friendly cleaner check out RidLyme.

Cleaning Solvents

The above multi-purpose cleaners should have eliminated any grease or dirt that would interfere with polishing and waxing, but some, like Don Casey, mention solvents. I personally don't do this step unless I'm painting, but there is nothing wrong with taking the extra step.

Casey recommends MEK over acetone. Interlux 202 Fiberglass Solvent Wash is another one that we've used. It seems to evaporate a little slower down here in Florida.

Also, we are looking at some "green" dewaxing solvents now from RPM technologies although these appear aimed at the industrial market.

Polishing Your Hull

Once you are assured you won't be driving grease and dirt deeper into the hull, you can begin polishing, or compounding. Be sure to wear goggles and a dust mask while doing this step. This process also removes any remaining old wax. Many wax manufacturers have a specific product that also includes a cleaning component (often petroleum-based) to get rid of grease and dirt. Collinite's Boat Cleaner 920 is an example.

How aggressively you want to polish your hull will depend on the hull condition. On a badly worn hull, you could wet sand with 800 grit wet-dry paper, followed by finer grits and then polishing compounds. If you've been waxing your hull regularly, and see no signs of oxidation, you might not even want to buff and skip to micro-finishing or waxing. Or, you could combine the buff and wax process into one with a one-step cleaner wax. We tested cleaner waxes back in 2007. The idea is to start with the least aggressive compound you need.

We tested heavy duty rubbing compounds in 2014, and that reports highlights some excellent products that will save you a great deal of time if you've got a lot of acreage to buff. Whether you call them buffing compounds, rubbing compounds, or polishes, they all work basically the same way: they contain a mild abrasive suspended in a liquid or paste that lighter abrades away surface imperfections and oxidation. The current trend is toward water-based products like Aqua Buff, which contain no petroleum distillates, but this product did not do nearly as well as others in our test. If you'd rather not wade through our test, I have had good luck with 3M Imperial Compound and Finishing Material, which contains distillates. Whatever compound you use, start with the mildest (highest # grit) that you need. Again, you don't want to remove more gelcoat than necessary.

For what power tools to use, see the power tool details above. In addition to the Superbuff pad mentioned before, I have also used 3M hook-It Velcro pads for polishing. In any case, I smear polish on the hull with a foam waxing pad and go VERY LIGHTLY at a low RPM. 3M recommends 1,000-1,500 RPM for its Imperial Finish. Keep the polisher moving to avoid heat buildup or over-polishing.

Micro-Finishes/Glaze

Many people skip this step, but I find it produces a better gloss if you do it, particularly when trying to restore the gloss to an older boat. We have not tested this product category. Essentially, this is an even finer polish than those used for compounding. For this, I use 3M Finesse It II. Several of the automotive-oriented waxes in our liquid wax test have similar products. On a small boat, you can apply it by hand, but I do it by machine. Again, apply light pressure and use a slow RPM, being careful to follow the instructions. Do a small area at a time.

Collinite Fleetwax has done consistently well in our boat wax tests.

Wax

Now that your hull is shiny, it is time to protect it. We've tested dozens of liquid waxes and paste waxes. Generally, the pastes offer harder protection that lasts longer and the liquids are easier to apply and last almost as long. I generally stick with the Collinite 885 paste wax. Contributing editor Frank Lanier, who waxed his hull by hand, found it too much work and was quite happy with the Collinite. A number of readers swear by the Nu Finish.

I usually use the the same tools I used for compounding, although I change to a clean pad. I usually apply the wax by hand using a foam microfiber pad, and then buff with the machine. Working in small areas. Don't let the Collinite 885 dry too hard, or it becomes hard to buff. Also, don't lay it on too thick. If you work in cooler temperatures, this can be a tough product to apply, but you can warm up the can slightly to soften it up. Usually, I have to go over the hull twice to get the shine. Sometimes I'll switch to a very soft buffing pad for this last step.

To help with your selection of waxes, here is the one-year report on Liquid Waxes.

And the six-month report on Paste Waxes

And finally a couple other resources that I found helpful.

Non-skid waxes

Gel Coat Repair Kits

Video

Jamestown Distributors has a pretty good video on refinishing an old hull using the 3M system. It's pretty heavy on the 3M products ads. Often, you can do just as well with products from your local Finish Master or similar auto-refinishing place. They also have a pretty good polishing kit that has everything you need, including the polisher.

If you have any questions on this topic or advice you'd like to share, post in the comments below or write to me at practicalsailor@belvoir.com.

Comments (5)

I have had good luck with my Makita buffers. They're not cheap. You did not mention them which I found surprising espeially since I observe many professionals using that brand.

Posted by: Jeffrey W | May 19, 2015 6:27 PM    Report this comment

We have used a wipe on-wipe off wax containing PTFE, or as Smtarbright calls it PTEF (we have used another)
Here on Long Island sound, we get a yellow-green stain on the boats. This product is the only one that lasts a season AND keeps off the crud. It's easy to apply and we have used it over Awlgrip with no bad effects. So far it's been four year since the boat was painted and we have NOT had to use polish first. Just soap and water.

Posted by: David S | May 13, 2015 9:59 AM    Report this comment

good review, however having restored an O'Day 23-2 back to mint, I now wonder what the yearly up keep procedure should be... I don't want to, nor need to, do the whole process over, but do want to maintain the gloss I have. Any thoughts?

Posted by: stuart c | March 20, 2014 9:31 AM    Report this comment

Good review. How about an AwlGrip hull. Is there any alternative to using the AwlGrip Wash and Polish?

Posted by: raycullum | January 28, 2013 2:03 PM    Report this comment

Thank you SO much for this comprehensive review. We are always looking for tips and tricks, and, your intro for the "type" of work we want to do was very insightful! This is exactly the kind of article I needed in order to approach my work (again) this year ;-)

Posted by: WAYNE T | May 16, 2011 3:03 PM    Report this comment


Add your comments ...

New to Practical Sailor? Register for Free!

Already Registered? Log in

Forgot your password? Click Here.