Homemade Mildew Preventers That Really Work

Posted by Darrell Nicholson at 04:13PM - Comments: (7)

October 14, 2013

Practical Sailor tested several mold preventatives on cotton-duck canvas.

If youíre getting ready to put your boat away this winter and are worried about mildew, then youíll definitely want to read our report in the November 2013 issue of Practical Sailor. PS tester Drew Frye made a pleasant little discovery when he was researching and testing various anti-mildew protectants earlier this month. Two inexpensive homemade concoctions did as well as or better than retail formulas that are 20 to 100 times more expensive. It wasnít a huge a surprise for Frye, who based the homebrew formulas on some of the more effective anti-mildew products from our previous tests.

The 13-product test field comprised liquid sprays, and gels and solids that work through emitting a vapor. The three vapor products were Star briteís NosGUARD SG, which reacts with water to release chlorine-dioxide gas; Forespar Tea Tree Power, a tea tree oil-based gel in a vented tub; and Pur-A-Fy Air from Natureís Innovative Solutions, a lemongrass oil-based gel.

PS contributor Drew Frye at work in his floating "lab," a PDQ 32 catamaran.

The liquid-spray group included Foresparís Tea Tree Oil Spray, Henkle Chemicalís Renuzit, Siamons Concrobium, the new Elite Marine Shield, and 3Mís Marine Mildew Block, which did well in our June 2010 test. Concrobium is available in liquid and vapor form; we tested the liquid. Our most effective commercial product, Goldshield 5 (diluted to the equivalent of Goldshield 75), is an quaternary ammonium formula developed by scientists at Emory University. As our dehumidifier field tests demonstrated, the first line of defense is controlling humidity. Something I have touched on in previoius blog posts about fighting mildew.

The two homemade spray formulas we tested each cost about one penny per ounce. Like the other mildew preventers in our test, you use these as cleaners by simply spraying the product on, wiping any excess away, and leaving it on. Before applying to any fabric, test the spray on an inconspicuous sample spot.

Formula A

1 quart hot water

1 tablespoon baking soda (sodium bicarbonate)

2 tablespoons washing soda (sodium carbonate)

2 tablespoons trisodium phosphate (TSP)

Much like Concrobium (which it is modeled after), our homemade Formula A removed the mildew from test carpet on board and kept it away, even though the area got wet again. It was also very effective in the moist-environment lab test.

Formula B

1 quart hot water

2 tablespoons baking soda

2 tablespoons Borax

1 tablespoon TSP

Formula B was the second-place performer in the liquid group. It was certainly the best value. It cleaned well, prevented mildew from returning to the carpet, and greatly slowed mildew infection in the moist-environment test in the lab.

We also tried treating with plain vinegar, which reportedly works on some hard surfaces, but testers found the smell a little too overpowering. A 10-percent solution of household bleach (3-percent sodium hypochlorite) was one of the best cleaners, but this has to be used with care. Bleach will bleed or degrade many fabrics, and can harm the marine environment. For complete results and more tips on keeping your boat mildew free, be sure to check out the entire article later this month at www.practical-sailor.com.

For serious cleaning jobs ahead, we also have an e-book dedicated to Marine Cleaners in our bookstore.

Comments (4)

I went to the website you listed in the article for the best performing "Elite Marine Shield". But, when I got there, there was no mention of this product anywhere on the site. I emailed the company and they replied that Practical Sailor garbled up some of the information and that their "Goldshield 5" is the product you actually tested. Please confirm.

Posted by: STEVE Z | November 3, 2013 1:25 PM    Report this comment

We did not test Kanberra gel in this comparison, but it also uses tea-tree oil like the Forespar products. We did try some Kanberra gel previously in a test boat in Florida, and results were comparable to what we found in the more controlled comparative testing done in the Chesapeake for this article. Seemed to help control mildew and odors, but was not as effective as other spray-products we used.

Posted by: DARRELL N | October 18, 2013 10:10 AM    Report this comment

The item tested that you called: "tea tree oil-based gel in a vented tub". Is this the product called Kanberra Gel or is it the same chemical?

Posted by: Larry C | October 16, 2013 10:28 AM    Report this comment

Washing soda? Never heard of it, so, where would I find it?

Posted by: JOHN T | October 15, 2013 9:51 AM    Report this comment


Add your comments ...

New to Practical Sailor? Register for Free!

Already Registered? Log in

Forgot your password? Click Here.