Insurance For Older Sailboats

Our survey results show that while it is possible to get insurance for older boats, it can be a challenge if you are a new client.

1
1978 Islander Bahama 30 that we’ve owned for just over 20 years. We keep her in good condition and therefore she is relatively easy for us to insure. (Photo/ Bert Vermeer)
1978 Islander Bahama 30 that we’ve owned for just over 20 years. We keep her in good condition and therefore she is relatively easy for us to insure. (Photo/ Bert Vermeer)

In our modern, risk-averse world, there is seldom the opportunity to stand alone—to be self-insured, as it were. Gone are the days when the average sailor can comfortably say, “If something breaks, I’ll just fix it!” With ever more complex systems aboard our boats, repair for even minor mishaps can become prohibitively expensive. In our marine world, comprehensive insurance policies are the norm, probably demanded by the marina we call home and the marinas we visit.

Insurance is now a way of life, the associated costs calculated into boat ownership. Unfortunately, there doesn’t appear to be a separation of insuring the vessel versus liability insurance. The reasoning seems to be that if a boat owner doesn’t care enough to insure the boat itself, there is probably a higher risk associated with liability.

How Insurers Assess Older Boats

Insurance companies are, by nature, risk-averse businesses. When seeking insurance as a boat owner, you either deal directly with the independent insurance company or go through an insurance broker who deals with a limited number of national or international underwriters. I suspect that somewhere in statistical analysis these companies have determined that providing coverage for your 40-plus-year-old classic plastic from the boom years of fiberglass boat building is not in their best interest.

To be fair, those 40-plus-year-old boats were not built to the same safety standards as more modern boats. Everything from electrical wiring to plumbing standards has changed dramatically over the years and continues to evolve as lessons are learned. Unless your pride and joy has been maintained and upgraded to comply with these modern standards, that reluctance is understandable. I suspect that the insurance world has probably learned that lesson the hard way.

What Owners Reported

A brief 2024 Practical Sailor survey specific to this issue was distributed to fellow sailors with older boats both north and south of the 49th parallel. The tipping point seems to be 40-plus years for most companies, as low as 15 years for some.

The results show that comprehensive insurance is available from some insurers, and not from others. Underwriters set the parameters; insurance brokers search for the underwriter with a policy that fits the applicant. Failure with the first application does not mean that insurance is not available.

The survey results indicate that a long-established client with the same boat is deemed a lower risk, so insurance is easier to maintain. However, a new client with a 40-plus-year-old boat is likely to have a more difficult time—no matter what the survey report indicates. There are underwriters that recognize “heritage boats,” those older boats that are maintained and upgraded to a high standard as identified by a survey report.

Boat Surveys Are Key for Policy Approval

<yoastmark class=

With few exceptions, the issued policy will be based on a report from an insurance company-approved surveyor at the time of purchase. With some companies, there is an additional requirement for surveys at specific intervals. The more restrictive policies require a specific rig inspection as well. There doesn’t appear to be a hard and fast rule on the east coast or west, north or south of the border.

Keep in mind that insurance companies, or underwriting agencies, rely completely on the survey report for risk evaluation. Even a company specializing in marine insurance is dependent upon that survey report. Although the insurance broker or underwriter may specialize in the personal marine environment, that does not equate to knowledge of specific sailboats, no matter what the age. Again, it is the knowledge of the surveyor that places an insurable value on the well-aged boat.

Bottom Line

The bottom line is that for a reputable, well-maintained older sailboat, insurance is still available—it just may be more difficult to find.

Further Resources:

 

This article was published on December 9, 2024, and has been updated.

Bert Vermeer
As a coastal cruise (and occasional racer & ocean crosser), Bert Vermeer has sailed the coast of British Columbia for over 40 years. With his wife Carey & daughter Nicky (and eventually granddaughter Natasha) in tow, Bert has gained an appreciation for the fabulous cruising grounds of the Canadian west coast. Based on his experience as a hands-on boater, he established a marine based business after completing his police career. Bert stays busy during the winter months dabbling in You Tube sailing videos and writing tales of summer adventures, awaiting blue skies and warm winds.

1 COMMENT

  1. My boats have all been 15-35 years old, so no problems with insurance. But consider this:
    * 80% of boat sinkings occur at the dock. The most common reasons relate to age; either corrosion, structural flaws, or hose failure.
    * Electrical fires are the next most common cause of total loss. The electrical system on a 40-year-old boat, even if upgraded, is likely to have a few older wires and components somewhere.
    * Resale and maintenance. My marina has many mature boats. Although the well-maintained boats are very sound, they require more maintenance to stay that way. A new boat will longer withstand neglect, and realistically, is less likely to be neglected (the owner has more to lose). And realistically, the resale value of many older boats is minimal, since the market is flooded.
    * Cleanup. Even liability policies require cleanup after a loss. Unlike a car that can be towed away and scrapped for a positive value, the marine insurance company faces refloating and possible environmental damamges, plus the cost to cut up the boat. Insurance companies get stuck with boats that are basically abandoned, but the insurance and slip still paid. I’ve seen many.

    It’s just business. In my mind, the insurance company asking for a basic survey at some frequency is like the safety inspection for your car, just less often and more expensive.