Roller Bearing Rudder Upgrade: A DIY Guide for Spade-Rudder Sailboats

Upgrading a spade rudder from nylon bushings to precision roller bearings is a major project, but this step-by-step account from a Cal 40 owner proves it's within reach for any careful DIYer.

4
CAD model detail showing modified tube end, 3D printed fairing piece and modified PET-P thrust washer. (Illustration/ Tom Egan)

Have you ever been sailing along and thought to yourself, something just doesn’t feel right. That is what happened to me with our steering on Misirlou, our ancient but venerable 1964 Cal 40. Like the proverbial frog in the pot of water heating up on the stove, the tightness and hard spots came on gradually, without me noticing at first.

But our rudder and bearings were new! I put them in myself, let’s see… (counting on fingers) 25 years ago. Okay, maybe not so new. Dropping the rudder after our end of season haul out revealed what I had expected: The nylon bushings were unevenly worn and out of round. The rudder stock was structurally sound but had surface scoring and pitting in the top and bottom bearing regions. Simply swapping the old bushings for new was not an option, given the surface condition of the rudder stock. An upgrade was needed.

When to Upgrade Rudder Bearings

There are many reasons to consider a rudder bearing upgrade. Normal wear and tear would be the most common. Maybe you hear a clunk when your boat gently rocks at anchor indicating excessive clearance between the stock and bearing. Maybe things were getting tight, like ours. Maybe you notice your autopilot straining or consuming more amperage than it used to. Maybe your steering is fine, but you want to get ahead of any future problems while doing a major refit.

Detail of our rudder bearing upgrade. A new rudder tube with top and bottom roller bearings replaces the 1964 OEM tube. (Drawing/ William Lapworth)

Perhaps you feel your tiller-steered boat would feel more like a yacht if you installed an all-new steering system with a wheel. Or, even better, maybe you want to lose over a hundred pounds of wheel, pedestal, quadrants cable and linkages from the weight-sensitive end of your boat and enjoy the simplicity and connectedness of a tiller. A friend did the wheel to tiller conversion on his J/105 race boat a while back. The J/105 comes equipped with roller rudder bearings, and it was the pure, frictionless feel of that tiller, more than anything else, that convinced me roller bearings were the way to go.

The Cal 40, designed in 1962 by William Lapworth for George Griffith was considered radical, possibly even dangerous, in its day for its light displacement, fin keel and spade rudder, has proven its worth and continues to win races to this day. (Drawing/ William Lapworth)

What follows is an account of my rudder roller bearing upgrade journey, and what I learned along the way. I hope it will be genuinely helpful to anyone considering a similar change to their steering system. Good planning and a stepwise approach make this an accessible job for the do-it-yourselfer with the proper tools and a working knowledge of, and practice with, fiberglass lay-up techniques. I have attempted to make what I have learned agnostic to boat design, but it is mostly applicable to fiberglass boats with spade rudders. Inevitably some of it will only apply to our Cal 40, but I have sequestered the nerdiest of Cal 40 content in a sidebar for those who care to read it.

Rudder Loads in a Nutshell

Our Cal 40 Misirlou sporting a 2001 era rudder upgrade by Carl Schumacher and new roller rudder bearings circa 2026.(Photo/ Tom Egan)

When the helm is centered and the boat is tracking, the rudder generates almost no side force. The moment you turn the wheel or push the tiller, water pushes sideways on the blade—that sideways push is what turns the boat. The harder the rudder is loaded (heeled over, hard on the wind, big seas), the bigger the push. On a 40-ft. boat in heavy weather, that push can run into the thousands of pounds, with peaks in a broach or hard round-up several times higher and coming on fast.

That sideways push acts down at the blade, well below where the post enters the hull. The two bearings—one at the bottom of the rudder tube, one at the top—are what hold the post against the load. And the geometry matters more than you’d think.

Loading diagram of rudders with different upper and lower bearing spacing and its effect on bearing loads. (Illustration/ Tom Egan)

Consider the diagram. Rudder A and Rudder B see the same 1,000-kg (2,205 lb.) side force on the blade, with the blade’s center of pressure 1 m below the lower bearing. The only difference is the spacing between the bearings—1 m on A, half a meter on B. With the bearings spread apart, the upper bearing pulls back at 1,000 kg (2,205 lb.) and the lower bearing pushes the other way at 2,000 kg (4,409 lb.). With the bearings packed closer together, the same blade load forces the upper bearing to 2,000 kg (4,409 lb.) and the lower to 3,000 kg (6,614 lb.). Halve the spacing, double the loads.

The bearings are reacting a moment, and a shorter lever means more force to do the same job. That’s why the lower bearing is always the harder-working one, and why naval architects like a tall rudder tube.

Misirlou’s “new” Carl Schumacher designed rudder from 2001 showing scoring, pitting, corrosion and surface irregularities from the
welded and drawn tube manufacturing process. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

Hitting Hard Objects

One more thing worth thinking about before we get to bearing selection. If you hit a submerged container—or encounter a frisky orca off the Iberian coast—and lose the rudder blade, you have a serious problem. You’re not steering, you’ll need a jury rig, probably a tow. See “Sailing Without a Rudder.” But you’re still floating. If the tube fails, you have a 3-in. hole in the bottom of the boat that you can’t get to and can’t easily plug. The rudder tube and bearing assembly should be stronger than the rudder blade itself. The blade is the sacrificial part. The tube is the hull. Worth keeping in mind through the rest of this article.

The Fix

Bearing Selection

Tides Marine, Vesconite, and others make high-quality polymer bushings that would have retrofitted to my existing rudder tube without much drama, and for a lot of boats that’s the right answer. I was set on roller bearings. For roller bearings on sailboat rudders, the active suppliers are Jefa, Lewmar, and Schuster. Harken used to be in the rudder bearing business and almost certainly supplied the bearings I’d admired on the J/105, but they’ve since exited that line. I also wanted no metal in the bearing assembly. That narrowed the marine field to Jefa and Lewmar. I briefly considered specifying non-metallic roller bearings from an industrial bearing supplier, but a rudder bearing is not the place to chase savings.

Originally, I naively hoped there was a rudder bearing out there that neatly fit in the anulus between my 3-in. rudder stock and my 3 1/2-in. ID tube. I emailed a few suppliers but it was the rep at PYI (the U.S. importer of Danish Jefa bearings) who patiently explained why this was not possible and laid out the reality of what was needed. It also helped that he had overseen several Cal 40 conversions on the west coast and was known and respected in the Cal 40 community. So, Jefa it is.

What We Bought

Jefa sells their bearing components two ways: à la carte (a fiberglass tube, an upper bearing, a lower bearing, all separate) or as an integrated assembly with one or both bearings already bonded into the tube at the factory. I went with the integrated approach for the lower bearing—Jefa’s 61000-series tube with the bottom bearing pre-bonded—and a loose upper bearing to be bonded in after dry-fitting and trimming the tube to length. Bonding the lower bearing at the factory takes one variable out of the layup; you know the lower bore is concentric to the tube before the tube ever sees the boat. The upper bearing has to wait because its position depends on the cockpit-sole geometry, which varies enough boat-to-boat that a factory bond doesn’t make sense.

Self-Aligning Bearings

Jefa also sells a series of self-aligning bearings. Usually fitted in the lower bearing position, these roller bearings in a spherical housing can rotate to self-align if the rudder stock bends under high load or if the boat flexes in a pounding sea. This is particularly a problem when the rudder tube is divided for a steering quadrant. Our situation, with a beefy rudder stock and continuous tube, did not call for a self-aligning bearing, but it may be a requirement for some boat design.

Machined Stainless Steel Sleeves

The uneven surface condition of our rudder stock was not going to cut it with a precision roller bearing. The solution is to bond machined stainless steel sleeves to the rudder stock for the rollers to ride on. The Jefa rep recommended an 82 mm OD on the upper and 84 mm OD on the lower—slightly different diameters so the rudder slides up through the upper bearing without binding on the way to its seated position at the lower. It’s the kind of detail you wouldn’t think of until you’d installed a few of these.

With all the components in hand, it’s time for action.

The Cal 40 Rudder Story
Legend has it that the first drawings of the Cal 40 were on a bar napkin when George Griffith was describing to naval architect William Lapworth a new, light, fast boat for the Transpac race he would like built. Griffith agreed to underwrite construction of the first ten boats, and the rest is history. Among other features considered radical, possibly dangerous, and definitely heretical to the staid yacht design community was a spade rudder, supported only by a fiberglass tube connecting the hull to the cockpit sole, without the additional support of a keel or skeg.

Overbuilt Rudder

Sixty-four years and several million ocean racing miles later, the design has proven its worth. The Cal 40 definitely has its quirks, but rudders breaking off isn’t one of them. This is due, in part, to the massively overbuilt rudder post of the original design. I can imagine Mr. Lapworth sitting at his drafting board imagining how his critics would crucify him if the rudders started snapping off his new design. So, having calculated the strength of the rudder stock needed to handle anticipated loads, he doubles it. Then doubles it again.

The resulting rudder design was a trapezoidal foil with a massive 3-in. schedule 40 stainless steel pipe (3.5 in. or 89 mm outside diameter) as the rudder stock, bent and flattened at the bottom to form the welded frame for the rudder. The stock passes through a simple fiberglass tube tabbed into the hull at the bottom and the cockpit sole at the top, capped with a bronze rudder head fitting and a long (5.5 ft., 1.65 m) tiller.

Turns On a Dime

This simple arrangement allows the rudder to turn 360 degrees. This gives the Cal 40 a party-trick ability to turn practically within its own length. Once a turn is initiated under power, putting the helm over 90 degrees arrests all forward motion, but turning momentum lets the boat pivot on its keel. I have given many a fuel dock attendant a near heart attack, spinning the boat in tight quarters surrounded by much more expensive yachts.

Rudder Issues

While the original rudder design has proven to be structurally sound, it is not without its problems. Rudders are balanced to have more foil area behind the rudder post centerline than in front. Otherwise, the foil would be unstable and try to flip around with forward motion. However, since spade rudders were relatively new territory, Lapworth seems to have overbalanced the area behind the centerline, giving the boats a wicked weather helm when fully loaded on a reach. The rudder blades were also prone to waterlogging and the rudder “bearing” was just the 3.5 in. OD pipe riding in a fiberglass tube packed with grease. Not exactly frictionless, especially when grit and marine growth worked their way in there.

New Schumacher Rudders

In the face of these shortcomings, in 2001 the Cal 40 Owners Association, based in southern California—where there are enough boats that Cal 40s still race as a one-design class—organized a group-buy of a new rudder designed by legendary naval architect Carl Schumacher.

The new rudder was a modern elliptical shape, higher aspect, better balanced and had a slightly smaller diameter stock (3.0 in. or 76 mm instead of the original 3.5 in. or 89 mm) allowing the fiberglass rudder tube in the hull to be fitted with top and bottom nylon bushings. The new rudder greatly improved the handling of the boat, especially while reaching. Because the rudder was offered to all owners, it was sanctioned as class legal for Cal 40 one design racing. The group-buy of over 20 rudders at a substantial discount illustrates the power of an organized, connected owners’ association.

The Project

Dropping the Rudder

Too-tall rudder in a tiny workshop. Modeling clay and electrical tape dam at bottom of masked upper sleeve visible at top of photo. Infusion tube is clamped following resin injection. Lower sleeve is visible through poly sheet. Rudder tube and upper bearing are visible on workbench to the left of the rudder. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

Getting the rudder out of the boat means hauling out with enough room beneath the keel to drop the full length of the rudder and stock below the hull. Misirlou’s rudder and stock are longer than her keel is deep, which is worth checking on your own boat before you call the yard. My asphalt boatyard in Marblehead frowns on digging holes, so I asked Ronnie the lift driver to put extra blocks under the keel and use longer jackstands. Ten minutes of planning saved the project.

Support the Rudder

The trailing edge of a spade rudder is a fine, sharp edge. There is a reason they call it a blade, and that fine, delicate edge is the first thing to hit the ground when you drop the rudder. Perhaps lower is a better word than drop. Before loosening any hardware, build a sturdy stack of blocks under the blade with padding on top and wedges driven up to hold positive upward pressure on the rudder. That stack protects the blade edge and holds the rudder against its top stop while the retaining hardware comes out.

Misirlou’s 3.0 inch rudder shaft, nylon bushing and OEM rudder tube protruding from the cockpit sole before the upgrade. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

Disassembly Sequence

Above the rudder, the disassembly sequence depends on what’s between you and the rudder head. Wheel-steered boats have a quadrant to remove. Boats with a below-deck autopilot of the tiller-arm type have an arm clamped to the stock. Where the tube is interrupted for the quadrant or autopilot, there’s usually a stuffing box, lip seal, or packing gland to be loosened. Then comes the rudder head fitting itself—on Misirlou, a pin and clamp; on wheel-steered boats, typically a deck access plate with an emergency-tiller drive and a recessed cross-pin. With the rudder blocked and under upward pressure, the cross-pin should come out easily. If it doesn’t, your blocking may have settled—restore the upward force and try again.

Misirlou’s original rudder tube in the lazarette. Note the separation of the tabbing on the upper portion of the tube from the bulkhead on the left. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

Ask for Help to Lower Rudder

If you have a strong back and a small boat, or have handled the rudder before and know what to expect, you may get away with bear hugging the rudder, kicking the blocks out of the way, and gently lowering the rudder by yourself. Use your knees, not your back. However, most spade rudders are designed to be slightly negatively buoyant and heavier than they look—a two- or three-person job. The moment to watch for is when the top of the stock clears the bottom of the tube: the rudder suddenly becomes top-heavy and wants to tip.

The tabbing tying the original rudder tube, cockpit sole and bulkhead together came off in one piece, saving a lot of grinding but throwing 1964 workmanship standards into question. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

Better than muscling it down is using mechanical advantage. Misirlou’s tubular rudder stock let me put a short pin through the cross-pin hole, loop a strap around the pin, and connect that strap to the main halyard. I was able to drop and raise the rudder single-handed that way, although it involved many trips up and down the ladder to incrementally lower and re-block. On a boat without a tall enough rig, a wooden tripod frame with a come-along, block and tackle, or chainfall does the same job. Past a certain size—call it any rudder you wouldn’t want to wrestle with at all—it’s time to call the yard.

Original rudder tube cut flush with cockpit in preparation for removal with a hole saw. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

Installing Bearing Sleeves

If your upgrade calls for bearing sleeves, and if you are replacing for wear issues, it probably will, you will need to bond these to the rudder stock. Before ordering, measure the stock carefully, noting any out-of-round or high points that might hang up on the sleeves—you do not want to get this measurement wrong. With sleeves in hand, the next job is bonding them in place with epoxy.

Jefa’s standard procedure is to coat both surfaces with epoxy, slide the sleeve on while rotating it for even coverage, and wipe the squeeze-out. That’s the right method for a clean, round stock. With the longitudinal ridges on mine, I was concerned that a single wet operation wouldn’t guarantee the two sleeves ended up concentric to each other. Dry fitting my sleeves showed a little bit of wobble, confirming there was no guarantee the two sleeves would be concentric if I glued them on the easy way, so I added an extra step.

How to Ensure the Sleeve Bond is Concentric

With the stock horizontal, I slid each sleeve into position and used small squares of masking tape between sleeve ID and stock OD to create a roughly uniform air gap—it was loose enough that each sleeve could still wobble slightly. Then I used a toothpick to push three evenly spaced dots of JB Weld putty up under each end of each sleeve. With the putty in place, I slid the bonded-bearing tube assembly down over the stock so the bearings located the sleeves, double-checked that nothing had shifted out of position, and let the putty cure overnight.

When I pulled the tube off the next day, the sleeves were locked to the stock at exactly the spacing and orientation the bearings would see in service. The remaining space between sleeve and stock was an empty annular gap waiting to be filled.

Filling the Gap

With the stock now vertical, I prepared a delivery dam at the bottom of each sleeve: a length of 1/8-in. plastic tubing with notches cut in the side wall, wrapped around the sleeve’s lower opening so the notches let epoxy weep through, sealed with modeling clay and electrical tape. I laid down a generous perimeter of masking tape and polyethylene sheet to catch overflow. To fill the gap, I half-filled a syringe with non-thickened epoxy, capped the end with a fingertip, and pulled the plunger back to de-gas it and push out the bubbles like a TV doctor, and injected it into the tube, slowly and evenly filling the annular gap between the stock OD and sleeve ID.

Lower-Viscosity Casting Epoxy

I used West System 105/205 because it was what I had on hand. In hindsight I would have sought out a lower-viscosity casting epoxy. The resin did flow into place under its own weight, as it should—we’re filling from the bottom and letting gravity do the work—but with 105/205’s viscosity it took sustained pressure on the syringe plunger and a fair amount of patience to push all the resin up through the annular space until it crested the top of the sleeve. A thinner resin would have done the same job with less hand fatigue. Voids in the bond are exactly what you don’t want here.

After cure, I peeled off the masking tape, dressed any drips, and followed Jefa’s recommendation by sealing the top and bottom edges of each sleeve with 3M 4200. That gives the sleeve-to-stock transition a flexible boundary that won’t trap water at the interface and won’t crack as the stock and sleeve see different thermal cycles.

With the sleeves bonded and sealed, it was time to make some itchy fiberglass dust.

Out With the Old

The Preparation

I’m going to assume that anyone with experience working with fiberglass has a working knowledge of PPE (personal protective equipment). A full face respirator with P100 particulate filters, heavy duty nitrile gloves, work boots and a full-body Tyvek hooded bunny suit with taped wrists and ankles is a must for grinding inside the boat.

I will also make a case here for BPE (Boat Protection Equipment). You will thank yourself later during the clean-up phase if you cover everything that is not the workspace, a path to the workspace, and a path to vent air out of the workspace.

Another consideration before cutting into the boat is accessibility. Do you realistically have enough room where the rudder tube passes through the boat for you and your tools to grind, sand and lay-up fiberglass? Believe me, this was borderline in Misirlou.

Cutting Out the Old Tube

The hole-saw tube removal technique. The hole saw’s center drill is replaced with a rod centered by wooden plugs at the top and bottom of the old rudder tube being removed. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

Misirlou’s old tube came out through the cockpit sole and the bottom of the hull rather than through the lazarette, which kept the messy work outside the cramped space. The technique I used kept the cuts perfectly aligned to the original rudder tube centerline, which is the geometry the new tube needs to inherit.

Preparing for bottom hole-saw-technique tube extraction cut. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

I cut two 3-in. OD wooden plugs from a scrap plank using a 3 1/8-in. hole saw—a snug fit for the 3-in. ID of the original tube. The center drill on the hole saw left a 1/4-in. pilot hole through the center of each plug. After cutting the portion of the old rudder tube that protruded into the cockpit flush with the sole, I tapped a plug into the top of the old tube bore and another into the bottom.

The extracted OEM rudder tube. Where the hole-saw’s depth of cut couldn’t reach, a reciprocating saw finished the job. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

The new Jefa tube has an OD of 130 mm, so I ordered a 5 1/8-in. (130 mm) hole saw and modified the arbor by removing its 1/4-in. center drill and replacing it with a length of 1/4-in. steel rod long enough to span from above the cockpit sole to below the hull. With the rod passed through the pilot holes in both plugs, the 5 1/8-in. hole saw was now centered, by definition, on the old tube’s centerline at both ends.

Upper hole ready to receive the new rudder tube. KiwiGrip around the hole has been removed using the soften-with-acetone technique. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

The bottom hole through the curved bottom of the hull cut through in one clean pass. The upper hole, through the cockpit sole at an angle to the centerline, started with the hole saw and finished with a reciprocating saw working to the scored circle. The result was two clean, perfectly sized, exactly co-axial holes, ready to receive the new tube.

Use a Corded Drill

As I learned the hard way, cutting through an inch of solid laminate with a 5-in. hole saw is not a job for a cordless drill held in one hand, as shown in the photos. Hardware-store hole saws at that diameter grab without warning, and the reaction torque will hurt your wrist or worse. Learn from my mistake and use a corded drill with a secondary D-handle, take it slow, keep the saw lubricated and the chips cleared, and be ready for the bite.

Preparing the Bonding Surfaces

With the old tube extracted, the next task was creating proper bonding surfaces for the new tube’s tabbing. The original upper tabbing on Misirlou had been a glob of coarse-weave mat and resin applied indifferently against the tube, the cockpit sole, and the adjacent bulkhead—I can imagine the production worker disliking that confined space as much as I did. The glob had already cracked away from the bulkhead, and the whole assembly pried off in one piece with a chisel and wrecking bar, saving me from grinding the original tabbing back to clean laminate.

The bottom tabbing got the full grinding treatment—about 8 in. back from the edge of the new hole, taken down to bare laminate. I also stripped paint and old tabbing from a 16-in.-wide swath running from the hull up to the cockpit sole on the lazarette side of the bulkhead, and ground the exposed bulkhead surface back to clean wood. That area wasn’t going to be tabbed directly.

The plan was to first laminate a 1/4-in. G10 composite panel from hull to cockpit sole as a reinforced bonding substrate for the new tube’s upper tabbing, and the same panel would carry the closure for the limber hole that converts the lazarette into a watertight compartment. Both come together in the next section.

The worst part was now done. Time for dry-fitting and the new layup.

In With the New

It is genuinely disconcerting to stand in the cockpit and see pavement through a 5-in. hole in the floor. It is also a sign that the hard part is done.

A Few Surprises Inside the Cockpit Sole

The hole through the plywood-cored cockpit sole revealed how Misirlou was originally put together. The freestanding rudder tube had been glassed into the hull, then the one-piece deck-cockpit-cabin-house molding was lowered over it. The deck-side hole had been generously oversized so the molding could be married to the hull without anyone fighting the tube into a precisely sized opening. Once the hull-deck joint was bonded and bolted, all the previously installed bulkheads and the rudder tube got tabbed to the underside of the deck from inside the boat.

The tabbing that came off in one piece in the previous section had been hiding a 1-in.-wide ring of chalky dried putty filling the gap between the plywood core of the cockpit sole and the rudder tube, and a 1/2-in. gap between the top of the plywood bulkhead and the underside of the cabin sole. The exposed plywood edges were dry, not delaminated, and not rotten. Marine plywood was good in 1964. A Dremel made short work of sanding the edges back to fresh wood, which I then sealed with unthickened epoxy.

The G10 Reinforcement

A sheet of ¼ inch G10 reinforces the bulkhead and forms one side of a structural triangle comprising the rudder tube, hull and bulkhead. It also seals off the limber hole making the lazarette a watertight compartment up to the rectangular openings that are well above the waterline. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

The new tube would not be tabbed directly to the wood bulkhead. Instead, a 1/4-in. G10 fiberglass panel—12 in. wide, spanning the full vertical distance from hull to cockpit sole—would be laminated to the lazarette side of the bulkhead first, and the new tube tabbing would land on the G10. The panel serves three purposes: it forms one side of a structural triangle (rudder tube, hull, bulkhead) significantly stiffer than the original construction; it provides a sound bonding substrate for the new tabbing; and it seals off the limber hole that previously drained the lazarette into the bilge, converting the lazarette into a watertight compartment up to the rectangular openings well above the waterline.

The panel was templated to fit, buttered with thickened epoxy, and clamped to the bulkhead with eight Vaseline-coated screws that would back out cleanly after cure. I troweled thickened epoxy into the gap between the top of the bulkhead and the underside of the cockpit sole, and used the squeeze-out from the panel itself to form a fillet around its edges.

Dry-Fitting and Bonding the New Tube

A wooden clamp with jack-screws is used to position the tube and hold the weight of the rudder for dry-fitting. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

With the G10 cured and the screws removed, I ran the 5 1/8-in. hole saw through the upper hole one more time to clean up minor epoxy squeeze-out, then turned to fitting the new Jefa tube.

I made a wooden collar for the tube out of a piece of 2×4, drilled to receive the tube and split so it could clamp around it, with threaded rods at each corner working as jack screws. The collar sits below the tube and supports both the tube’s weight and the rudder’s weight during dry-fit. Turning the jack screws raises or lowers the entire assembly by fractions of an inch, which is exactly the precision needed to land the rudder in the right vertical position.

A “finger” ahead of the rudder keeps rope and seaweed from lodging in the gap between the hull and rudder. The finger must stick down past the top of the rudder for this to work. The rudder has no stops, and so the finger must not damage the rudder if it turns 180 degrees. These factors determine the vertical position of the rudder tube. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

The Right Vertical Position

Why does vertical position matter? Two reasons. The first is rudder-to-hull clearance—too high and the rudder binds against the hull, too low and you’ve given up control authority.

The second, on Misirlou, is the finger: a small streamlined fairing molded into the hull just ahead of the rudder leading edge that keeps lobster pot warp and seaweed from working into the gap between the hull and the rudder. We live in the land of lobster pots, and the finger earns its keep. For it to do its job, the top front corner of the rudder needs to sit just behind the finger. But the rudder has no mechanical stops; if it ever swings 180 degrees, the back of the rudder needs to clear the same finger without damage. Those two constraints determine the vertical position of the tube within roughly a quarter inch.

The new tube is bonded in place using thickened epoxy, which is filleted in four places, top and bottom, inside and out. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

With the tube, upper bearing, rudder, and rudder head all dry-fitted together, I worked the jack screws until the geometry was right at both ends, then marked the tube position. With the rudder and bearings removed but the jack screws holding the tube exactly where I wanted it, I mixed thickened epoxy and bonded the tube to the hull at the bottom and to the cockpit sole at the top, with fillets in four places: top and bottom, inside and out. The fillets do two jobs—they give the tabbing a continuous radius to land on rather than a sharp corner, and they carry a meaningful share of the structural load on their own.

The new tube is bonded in place using thickened epoxy, which is filleted in four places, top and bottom, inside and out. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

Tabbing Schedule

The four locations where the tube meets boat structure each have different demands. The bottom-outside, where the tube exits the hull, has to be watertight and streamlined to minimize drag. The bottom-inside, in the lazarette, is where most of the lower bearing’s reaction force lands and needs to be very strong (remember the lever-arm picture in section 3). The top-inside ties the cockpit sole, bulkhead, and tube together and also has to be strong. The top-outside has to be watertight and reasonably presentable, since people will see it.

The new tube is tabbed to the hull, cockpit sole and bulkhead with six tapering layers of 1708 biaxial fiberglass cloth and West System epoxy.(Photo/ Tom Egan)

Laying Up the Fiberglass

My research suggested five or more layers of 1708 biaxial cloth in epoxy, each layer overlapping the last in increasing widths, would handle the structural locations. I started with 4-in. strips at the tube—2 in. on the tube, 2 in. on the hull or sole—and added 1 in. of overlap per layer for six total layers, working two layers at a time and sanding between sessions. The G10 panel got three layers of 1708 tabbing it to the hull and to the underside of the cockpit sole.

“Why didn’t you use peel-ply to avoid all that sanding?” I hear someone ask. I’d judged the top-hat-shaped bottom joint and the convoluted upper joint too awkward to peel-ply cleanly. After several sessions sanding cured epoxy in a tight lazarette, I wish I had tried harder. Adapt peel-ply if you possibly can.

Why the Brown Epoxy?

A note about the brown epoxy in the photos. Lamination day was 50 F (10 C), too cold for the new can of West System 206 slow hardener I had bought, so I had to use an older can of 205 fast hardener that could be used down to 40 F (4 C). The old can had oxidized and turned brown, but the internet assures me oxidation does not affect strength.

For Wheel-Steered Boats

For wheel-steered boats, this is the point at which you would cut the tube to make space for the steering quadrant or autopilot tiller arm—after both ends are tabbed in place and the bearings are aligned, never before. A divided tube loses some of the structural continuity of the original; if I were doing this on a wheel-steered boat, I would increase the tabbing schedule at both half-tube ends and consider glassing G10 buttresses to support the lower half-tube against the bulkhead.

The Bottom Outside: Thrust Washer and Fairing

To reduce drag, the sides of the rudder tube are trimmed and a streamlined shape is sculpted from fairing compound. A PET-P thrust washer (white) handles any upward load from the rudder and a 3D printed fairing part (black) positions the washer and is removable for bearing servicing. Note, the rudder is lowered a few inches to show detail. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

Jefa’s standard arrangement uses a PET-P thrust washer between the bottom of the rudder and the bottom of the tube to carry any upward load from the buoyancy of the rudder. As supplied, this leaves the squared-off 5-in. OD tube end protruding past the 3 1/2-in.-wide rudder blade—directly in the slipstream. I am, perhaps obsessively, opposed to drag I can do something about.

I trimmed the sides of the tube back to the bearing flange and designed a 3D-printed part that fills in the trimmed sides of the tube while positioning the PET-P thrust washer (also cut down to match the new profile). The printed part is held in place by the fairing compound around it but, critically, can be removed for future bearing service—it was Vaseline-coated before fairing so the fairing compound wouldn’t bond to it.

Barrier coat on and ready for bottom paint. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

Fairing and Sanding

With the area around the tube exit already sanded back to gelcoat, I troweled on TotalBoat TotalFair around the protruding tube and printed part, sculpting a smooth shape that flows into the hull. Three rounds of fairing compound, sanding between, took it to a shape that’s hard to distinguish from a molded-in fairing. TotalFair is rated for below-waterline use but has to be sealed; I gave the faired area and the rudder itself three coats of Interlux Interprotect 2000E, followed by our usual red ablative bottom paint.

First coats of paint on finished rudder tube installation. The limber hole plug not yet installed in this photo. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

The Top Outside: Looking Presentable

The cockpit-side tube/sole joint had been filleted with thickened epoxy during the bonding step. I went over it with a larger-radius application of TotalFair, sanded smooth, and finished with three coats of leftover Alexseal Matterhorn White to match the cockpit. If you’re doing this on a gelcoat-finished boat instead of a painted one, substitute a polyester fairing compound for the TotalFair and finish the area in gelcoat with wax added to the final coat for a hard cure.

Dealing with KiwiGrip

One last trick worth passing along. The KiwiGrip non-skid that runs across the cockpit sole used to butt against the original rudder tube. The new 5 1/8-in. tube needed a slightly larger KiwiGrip-free zone. KiwiGrip’s care instructions warn against using acetone near the product, which gave me an idea. Testing in an inconspicuous spot, I found acetone dissolves KiwiGrip into a goo that wipes away with a rag, and once the acetone flashes off, the surrounding KiwiGrip seems to recover its original properties.

A mild paint remover like Citristrip also works well and gives more working time. Mask off the KiwiGrip you want to keep, gently wipe away the goo from the area you want clear, pull the tape, and rinse thoroughly with water as the surviving edge re-hardens.

Reassembly

Painted upper tube with bearing, rudder head and tiller installed. (Photo/ Tom Egan)

With all the glasswork and finishing done, the new system went together quickly. I bonded the upper bearing into its bore with a deliberately small amount of 3M 4200—enough to keep the bearing from rotating in service, not enough to make removal hard if it ever needs to come out. The rudder went up through the bottom, all the spacers and washers landed in their proper order, the rudder head clamped on, the cross pin slid home, the tiller went on, and we were ready to launch.

Sea Trial, Maintenance, and What to Expect After a Season

Rudder now turns so freely it must be restrained while at the mooring. (Photo: Tom Egan)

Now for the fun part. Everything reassembled, the boat back in the water, the tools put away, let’s go sailing.

The first thing I noticed was that the tiller feel was back. The subtle weather helm changes, the small vibration that telegraphs a luffing sail, the way the rudder bites when the helm is thrown over for a fast tack—all of it transmitted through the tiller with no clunk, no rumble, no resistance to swim through.

If your bearings were as bad as ours before the upgrade, your autopilot may need a gain adjustment: a system that had been working harder to overcome friction will now move the rudder farther per command than it used to.

Maintenance

Jefa describes their bearings as essentially maintenance-free, but two warnings appear on their website in big red letters: do not put any grease between the rollers, and do not put any antifouling on the rudder stock or in the bearing housing.

The one piece of annual maintenance they do recommend is flushing the lower, submerged bearing with fresh water. If you sail in sandy or silty water, an occasional flush of the upper bearing is worth adding to the list. If something does go wrong with either bearing, they can be disassembled and rebuilt rather than replaced wholesale.

Electrolysis

The other major watch-out Jefa flags is electrolytic corrosion in the bearing area. The bearings themselves are all polymer and can’t cause electrolysis, but corrosion on the rudder stock or sleeve where the rollers run will quickly destroy the rollers in turn. Stray marina currents, dissimilar metals in the steering system, even metal-based bottom paint applied too close to the rudder stock can all set off problems.

Jefa’s website carries a few genuinely horrifying photographs of pitted and corroded rudder stocks that will motivate you to take this seriously.

The One-Year Inspection

I’m planning to ask Ronnie to block us up high again this fall for a rudder drop and one-year inspection. The checklist is short: electrolytic damage on the sleeves, marine growth in the lower bearing, and general condition of the tube, the tabbing, and the G10 reinforcement.

I’ll also be doing something I intended to do from the start and forgot until the boat was in the water: installing a hose fitting in the rudder tube, above the waterline, to make flushing easier in future years. The new tube is essentially a sealed system, and getting fresh water to the lower bearing currently means dropping the rudder a few inches with the boat hauled.

A small bronze or composite hose fitting bonded into the side of the tube turns the annual flush into a five-minute job at the dock. I’ll do it with the rudder out so I can keep drill dust out of the bearing.

Worth It?

It is still early in our season with the new bearings, but the verdict so far is unambiguous. On the mooring, Misirlou swings so freely on her rudder that I’ve had to rig a rope harness to keep the tiller centered, something that was never needed before. Under sail, the experience is sublime: friction-free communication between my hand and the water moving under the boat.

Tom Egan
Tom Egan is an engineer, inventor and lifelong sailor who cruises and races out of his home port Marblehead, Mass on his Cal 40 Misirlou, and just about any boat that will have him.

4 COMMENTS

  1. Very cool and nicely done.

    In contrast, I made new rudder bushings for my F-24 from trimmed PVC pipe bushings ~ 7 years ago. Still very tight and smooth. It turned out the original bushings were very, very close to a 1 1/2- x 2-inch pipe bushing, including the flange dimensions, and just a little fine-tuning with a drum and disk sander created a perfect fit. I can steer with my pinky, and there is zero play. I could have turned something on the lathe, but it would not have been any better, in this specific case.

    PVC is not a perfect bearing material, but it is used for this, they were oversize (2-inch rudder stock on a well-balanced 1500-pound boat), it is slippery and wear-resistant enough, and resists sunlight better than some alternatives. (They are exposed when the rudder is tipped up–the cause of failure was UV damage to the flanges, not wear. The rudder stock was not worn.) PVC does not swell in water (nylon, for example, can be a problem in that way).

    Food for thought, for smaller boats. I would have done something more like the article for my cruising cat. Very nice.

    • Great resourcefulness using PVC for the bearing swap! PVC isn’t known for great wear resistance (see https://www.azom.com/article.aspx?ArticleID=4101) but should offer many years of service. You are absolutely correct about nylon swelling as it absorbs water. I had nylon bearings because that is what was supplied with the rudder group-buy. Every season, just after launch, the rudder would bind-up from surface swelling of the bearings. A week later, when the full volume of the bearing was hydrated, the steering would free up again. Jefa uses PET-P for their wear surfaces.

  2. Excellent project and well written article.
    Tip for using peel-ply on odd shapes: Cut and laminate many small overlapping pieces, as if bird feathers or fish scales, instead of larger sheets. Tall-ish trapezoid shapes work well in the transitions from flats to tubes or conical shapes. Be sure to leave dry edges on the peel ply for a grip to peel.