
Let’s dig into the truth to the 75-80% power reduction claims for Energy Recovery Watermakers, review some comparison data, chat with the inventors, and discuss who I think an ER watermaker—and its hefty budget—makes sense for.
After going no-generator-all-lithium a few years back, all new equipment that goes on Connie has to fit into our (mostly solar-generated) power budget. And it was long past time to re-add watermaking to Connie‘s list of skills.
There’s a big allure to the Energy Recovery—or “ER”—watermakers, namely the promise to use a fraction of the power per gallon/liter. “Save 75-80% energy per liter/gallon!” is prominently featured in every ER manufacturer’s marketing materials. Sounds like some real-world testing on Connie is in order.
Long story short, we decided to test out a Schenker Smart 60, and found that the claims can be true, but strangely not under the advertised circumstances.
Was it worth it? For Connie‘s generator-less setup, yes, I believe so. For those not looking to ditch the generator? Very questionable. There’s the premium cost, added complexity, and, depending on the manufacturer, various additional points of failure.
Energy Recovery vs. Conventional Comparison
Instead of wasting the pressure in the salty reject stream (brine), an energy-recovery device (ERD) captures that pressure and uses it to help pressurize the next slug of seawater going into the membrane—which means your electrical pump doesn’t have to do all the work.
A conventional watermaker uses a beefy high-pressure pump to push all the incoming seawater through the membrane. The brine leaves the membrane still at very high pressure and is then thrown away across a valve—along with that energy. In an ER system, the brine’s pressure is handed back to the incoming seawater through a pressure-exchange or intensifier mechanism.
In the past, there were very few energy recovery options—Spectra being the original followed by Schenker out of Italy. Now we have options from the likes of ElectroMaax, Osmosea, Aqua-Base, Parker, Eco-sistems, and Blue Gold.
Depending on where you live, availability of these newer brands may be scarce, however. Parts and support may be even scarcer.
Comparison Table of Energy Recovery vs. Conventional Watermakers
There are many watermaker manufacturers targeting the recreational marine industry, but let’s focus on common ones that I’ve actually seen installed on boats in the wild—and not just in booths at boat shows.
We’ll compare a couple of energy recovery (ER) watermakers with a few conventional units. Note that there are watermakers with rated outputs all across the range for both ER and conventional. However, as we’ll discuss, most conventional watermakers that people own are going to have a much higher total rated output than an ER, as you’ll see in my examples below.
Pay special attention to the “W/L” or Watts per Liter in the table below:
| Model | Type | W/L | Power Draw | Output | Base Price | Country of Manufacture |
| Schenker Smart 60 | ER | 4.0 | 240 W | 60 L/h (15.8 gph) | ~$10,800 (base) | Italy |
| Spectra Newport 400C | ER | ~4.0–4.8 | ≈270–290 W (12V×24A) | ~64 L/h (17 gph) | ~$16,500 | USA |
| ElectroMaax Solarmaax 340 | ER | ~3.9 | 250 W | 64 L/h (17 gph) | $8,395 | Canada |
| SCLE Aqua-Base FIJI | ER | ~4.6 | 300W | 65 L/h (17 gph) | $8,500 | France |
| Cruise RO SMDC-33 (12V) | Conventional | ~8.5 | ≈1,060 W | 125 L/h (33 gph) | ~$6,450 | USA |
| SeaWater Pro AC 40 GPH | Conventional | ~6.4 | 970 W | 151 L/h (40 gph) | ~$4,250 | USA |
| Rainman AC Modular 140 | Conventional | ~8.9 | 1,250 W | 140 L/h (37 gph) | ~$5,000 | Australia |
A few notes on this table:
- Prices are from United States distributors as publicly available at the time of writing and may vary drastically by country.
- There are a number of conventional AC watermakers that I have personally seen at boat shows that are in the $10,000-15,000 range for the same 40 gph output. I have not included these, as I have never seen one in the wild.
- Price comparison gets very muddy when you start adding options, especially automatic features. The Rainman, for instance, goes from $5,000 to $10,000 in a hurry.
We can see that based on just the advertised specs, the gains in W/L are impressive, but 75-80% power reduction seems like some pure marketing nonsense.
When we put it to the test, though, our Schenker ER unit can actually live up to the marketing claims, albeit when it’s set to half capacity.
Our One-Year Test of the Schenker Smart 60—Sipping Power

The headline efficiency of 75% energy savings vs traditional did show up for us but only running it on single-pump mode. The Schenker Smart 60 actually has two pumps, allowing you to run only one at a time to run at half power usage. Pretty neat.
With one pump, the Smart 60 was producing 40-42 liters per hour (10.5-11 gph) at only 110 W. That’s a seriously impressive 2.75 W/L. However, in dual pump mode, the watermaker hits (or slightly beats) the advertised 60 L/h at about 240 W, but efficiency falls back toward about 4 W/L.

The power usage for one pump is so low that it barely requires any consideration in our power budget. If we’re starting the watermaker as we leave the boat, the solar more than keeps up, and we usually come back to fresh water and full batteries.
Is there a catch to running it with one pump? Possibly.
In my discussion with the CEO of SLCE Aqua-Base watermakers, Benjamin Gury, he questions the viability of such a solution:
“The idea of using the Schenker unit with only one pump instead of the two has the advantage of reducing the power consumption. However, the quality of the water produced will be greatly reduced. It would be the same with any watermaker as the size/number of membranes are related to the seawater flow and the production flow needed. If you have some margin around the nominal point, 50% flow variation is too much in my point of view.”
Schenker advertises the use of a single pump as a sanctioned power saving feature in their documentation. So, it looks like we have some additional testing to do.
Quick note: Almost all of our testing was done in ideal watermaking conditions thus far—clear, warm Caribbean waters. The conditions can have a significant impact on water production, so we’ll have to provide updates as we do further testing.
To Generator or Not to Generator
As I mentioned earlier, most of the conventional watermakers that I see in the wild are going to have a much higher rated output than energy recovery. That’s because folks are going to want to optimize for different things. If you’re using a conventional watermaker, the goal is to produce water as quickly as possible to minimize generator runtime. The energy reduction is much less important since you’re producing so much power anyway.
Cruisers tend to run all of their high load appliances at the same time while the generator is running, so energy reduction can have an impact if you’re already reaching limits in your generator output. But most folks can comfortably run a watermaker, an air conditioner or two, and the water heater, as well as still get some battery charging in there.
However, if you’re one of the many that is on the mission to get rid of the generator entirely or only run it sparingly, this equation changes completely.
Who is an Energy Recovery Watermaker For?
The Case That a Generator Is Becoming Irrelevant
If you’re at the stage that your generator is ready to be retired or you’ve outgrown your current generator—or maybe you just don’t want to hear an engine ruining your most peaceful anchor moments—you’ve already got significant investments to make.
Today’s marine generator can easily start at $15,000 before even discussing the installation. In our case, to even remove the old generator, we had to dismantle part of a stateroom ceiling, hire a crane, pull the propulsion engine, and then have a crew help us get the generator out. That’s a lot of your budget that can be put into other systems. And, on a catamaran, that’s some decent weight savings.
Today’s marine tech gives us high output alternators, smart regulators, and many more solar options than before—plus cheap lithium battery options to store all of that energy. If you’re looking to squeeze in more solar, see my article on the new CIGS panel construction and its advantages.
The upsides, of course, are not having a whole entire extra engine to maintain and your peace and quiet at anchor. However, the tradeoff is that we’re on a much stricter power budget, and power efficient marine systems are more expensive and often more complicated.
Does More Complexity Mean More Maintenance and More Failures?
The process that ER systems employ means that there’s a bunch of new parts that are going to be taking abuse. When I listen to the signature “heartbeat” from an ER watermaker, I hear a combination of innovation and components taking abuse.
The ElectroMaax Solution
Let’s look at ElectroMaax’s take on this problem. Their goals are to make wear parts more serviceable, and upgrade various parts to titanium for a longer service life.
The video below, while a bit dry, is a great explanation of what ElectroMaax focused on tweaking. It’s also a good explanation of additional maintenance to be expected and what failure points look like.
This Clark Pump based design, for instance, still requires piston maintenance, seals to be changed, and various other wear parts that need to be monitored. And incorrect maintenance or operation can cause catastrophic failures.
The Schenker 2.0 and Discussion with Schenker’s Founder
As for Schenker, a number of years ago, they released a version 2.0 of their ERS. Riccardo Verde, Founder & CEO of Schenker, was kind enough to walk me through it:
“It’s worth noting that Schenker introduced version 2.0 a few years ago, eliminating all internal seals and O-rings. The sealing elements were replaced with innovative composite pads, which offer even greater wear resistance than steel. The result is that the current Schenker ERS is a virtually maintenance-free component, successfully tested for years of continuous use. Of course, the only condition is that the water be properly filtered (using appropriate pre-filters, replaced regularly), preventing sand, coral, or sediment from entering the system.
I don’t entirely agree that all energy recovery (ER) watermakers tend to be less reliable than traditional watermakers. It’s certainly true that ER watermakers include an additional component, the ERS, which potentially introduces a failure risk.
[…]ER watermakers, on the other hand, don’t make use of high-pressure pump of traditional watermakers, which is a critical component and a frequent source of failure. In fact, high-pressure pumps, which push water through the membrane with brutal force, are generally three-plunger metal pumps, designed for very different applications, typically car washes.
Using these pumps with a highly aggressive fluid like seawater makes the application quite critical, and failures of high-pressure pumps in traditional systems are quite common.” -Riccardo Verde, Founder, Schenker Watermakers
In a separate conversation with Benjamin Gury, CEO of SLCE (Aqua-Base Watermakers), he also added the following:
“In terms of lifespan, our ERD runs at low speed (one switch every 6 seconds on a 65 L/h system), which allows us to reach a very long life span on the seals. Considering the low running hours on most sailing boats, it would be decades.”
We have come a long way into making ER more reliable for cruising. There is still the issue of using specialized equipment versus widely available parts. Though, any world travelers would undoubtedly want to keep spares of main components, like pumps, for serious off the grid adventures, regardless of the type of watermaker.
Automation Features Add Even More Complexity
For our install, I added Schenker’s touch panel and all the optional sensors that go with it—automatic salinity divert, flow, and pressure. That’s roughly $2,000 worth of add-ons.
This makes the unit very set-it-and-forget-it. If we’re producing less water per hour than a conventional, we’re running the unit for longer and more often. But a goal of this whole generator-less setup is more nature sounds, less mechanical noise.
In actual usage, we wanted to be able to just hit a button on our way off the boat to our next adventure mission and arrive back stocked up with freshly made water.
With the added salinity sensor and diverter relay, the unit knows when the water salinity level is safe, and automatically diverts it to the tank, without any user input. With an extra button push at startup, the unit also auto-flushes itself with fresh water after the run—extremely important if you don’t want to severely reduce the lifespan of your expensive components.
This is all managed from the remote panel, which is very helpful for anyone whose watermaker is tucked away in an engine compartment or any hard-to-get-to space.
All this culminates into a great experience so far running the watermaker. We hit two buttons before hopping off the boat and come back to fresh water. If cruising is about spending a lot of money to make everything in life harder, these conveniences won’t aid in that quest.
Schenker-Specific Install Learnings
These may all be specific to the Schenker install, but I suspect similar issues to exist across the industry. Watermaker companies are generally small manufacturers. If you’re expecting a Victron level of polished documentation, Schenker’s manuals and labeling is going to be quite lacking.
The documentation in my box didn’t include the optional wiring diagrams for the touch panel, flow sensor, and pressure transducer. They exist—they just weren’t there.
The English translation in the manual is serviceable but occasionally asks for a second pass. Coupled with the organization, you might end up doing something like ordering ¾-in. hose after seeing the spec for ¾-in. through-hulls, when pages later you’ll see that a 5/8-in. hose is actually the spec.
Also, the feed pumps are more sensitive to getting enough water flow than the manual will lead you to believe. My seawater inlet is within the specified distance from the pump group. However, in full power (both pumps) mode, I still had cavitation problems from the pump’s not getting enough water.
I figured that my run was a bit too complicated, and that was confirmed by Rich from Cruise RO Water and Power, a U.S. importer for Schenker Watermakers. Ninety-degree bends are an issue for the run.
I also wish that the Schenker came with NMEA 2000 integration. There is an expensive optional box that can be added for MFD integration, however, I see no reason why N2k can’t be built directly into the remote panel and then easily connected to the N2k network. This would allow me to get all the data into SignalK and provide easy remote monitoring when we’re away from the boat.
NMEA licensing costs play a role here, understandably. SLCE (Aqua-Base Watermakers), had this to say about excluding NMEA for their own watermakers:
“NMEA2000 is very expensive to get and to keep. It is not a technical issue. It is a fee issue to the NMEA organization.”
-Benjamin Gury, CEO, SLCE Watermakers
Conclusion
The innovations focused on reliability and maintenance have broadened the range of who should consider an ER watermaker. Given the added complexity and increased cost, I still think that they make the most sense if you’re on a generator-less or generator-minimizing mission like we are. In fact, it’s kind of a must-have if you’re heading into this journey.
I do think that the automation features (on any watermaker) change the way we handle watermaking. It’s squarely in the quality-of-life improvement category, albeit at a hefty price tag.
If you’ve got questions or have an energy recovery watermaker nightmare to share, drop a line in the comments to help folks who are also making this investment.















I would love to see results from your schenker RO where the quality of the output at one pump is compared to a sample in two pump mode. My LIMITED understanding of how RO membranes work would suggest that lower flow should produce a better product if any difference at all. But I am not expert in this field. But I do think the Watts per Litre is an important metric.
This is the first I’ve read on ER water makers. Your comments on noise resonate (Ha!) with me but in addition to the noise of the genset, our Rainman water maker is pretty noisy all on its own. How noisy is your system with one pump? With two?
There are ways to reduce noise of a conventional system – I suggest using rubber feet to mount, and isolating the pump and motor from the inner hull for starters.
We’ve had guests ask us about the phantom noise that they’re hearing in the background. They can’t quite make out. Do we have a water pump running? Is that a problem? When I tell them that it’s the watermaker, they’re often quite surprised.
The ER watermakers do have a bit of a “heartbeat” sound as the clark pump (or variation) does its thing. I likely wouldn’t want to sleep above one.
Ours is in our engine compartment, which has sound dampening foam, and it’s really not all that noticeable. Angie is more bothered with the sound of the water filling up an aluminum tank than the watermaker itself.
I have the same interest as Carl. Be interested to know if the competitor company exec’s opinion is true. Is there a difference in the quality of the water output using Schenker’s one pump compared to using the two pump output. Thanks Adam for the article. I agree, automation is the way to go.
First off, I’m a Seawater Pro dealer, and have had one of their units on board my boat now for over six years. With that out of the way, the entire discussion of saving energy is a bogus one in my opinion. A proper cruising boat should be set up to accommodate all of the power demands of its equipment, and do so at a reasonable – dare I say “rational” – cost?
Paying from 2.5 to 4 times as much for less than half the production doesn’t say efficiency at all, it means more than twice the wear and tear on the gear – AND your wallet. Energy efficiency ONLY has value when energy is scarce, and for most modern cruising boats, energy is no longer the scarce resource it once was.
Furthermore, and the article doesn’t address this – where are you going to store all of this wonderful spare energy you suddenly have? Last I heard, ohms didn’t fit will in most lockers, watt every else you might claim.
For example – the Seawater Pro 40 gph unit runs at 970 watts, so in two hours of watermaking, you’re 1900 watt-hours, or roughly 140-160 amp-hours depending on charging voltage. If you’ve designed your solar at 900 watts – easily achieved these days on most cruising boats – and run from 10 am to noon, you’ll be down 25 – 35 amps, which is no problem for a lithium battery bank at all, and easily recovered on a lead acid bank.
Since you’ve already made the investment in solar power and batteries for the rest of your boat, does it make sense to spend a huge amount of money to save – nothing?
To put this another way, for the cost of an ER watermaker, you could buy a conventional watermaker, 800 – 1200 amp hours of LiFePo4 battery bank, and 1200 watts of solar. Then, instead of spending your entire day babysitting your watermaker (I don’t believe in letting gear run unattended), you can make your 40 gallons during breakfast and spend the rest of the day snorkeling or exploring.
If I’ve left you with the following question, I’ve made my point – Would I rather have an ultra-efficient watermaker… or a huge electrical system that benefits every appliance on the boat?
Hi Wally. Appreciate different perspectives and everyone’s mileage will vary. On Connie, we’ve got 2100 watts of solar. In the summer months, we’re often spoilt for choice with power. But, in the winter months in the Caribbean, we’re often blowing through it all. On the way down from the Chesapeake this year, we’re rationing our power budget. If we have 2 or even 4 guests that are using our systems and charging all of their devices, power gets even tighter.
I’ve tried my best to write the article in a way that balances the power consumption, added complexity, generator discussion, and progress made in ER systems in a way that folks can make decisions on what’s right for their situation.
We have the 30 litre an hour Schenker running from solar and lithium batteries, and if that is low charge, then the alternator. It is efficient and provides all that we need. If we need more fresh water we just run it for an extra hour, so can see no point in having a larger unit and running it for shorter time or on half power. We only run it when we know the seawater is clear and clean. I would never run it when leaving the boat, as most places where we can dock or anchor are somewhat murky. If mounted away from the salon, with vibration isolation the noise is not a problem. Ideally I run it on any part of a passage where we are motor sailing, which is more often than we want. Typically too much wind or not enough.
I agree that the Schencker is really not very loud. We’ve had guests over the boat and very surprised that the phantom noise they’re hearing is actually the watermaker running. The only thing that annoys Angie is the sound of the water dropping into a near-empty aluminum tank!