Engine Spares for the Cruising Sailor

Posted by Darrell Nicholson with Nick Nicholson at 01:17PM - Comments: (8)

Dan Dickison
Dan Dickison

An ample supply of spare parts can help keep "The Beast" happy while cruising for extended periods.

Cruising sailors rely on their engines a lot more than they like to admit. Although the internet has helped close the gap between parts suppliers and cruising sailors in far corners of the earth, the long-term cruiser still has to carefully consider which spare parts and supplies he needs to carry with him.

A list of recommended spare parts will vary slightly by what brand you engine you have and where you are cruising. Parts for our old Volvo MD2B were expensive and hard to find anywhere, so my wife Theresa and I had to balance our desire to be self-sufficient with our meager budget. In Panama, we were able to scavenge spares from an old MD series engine with a cracked block, saving us hundreds of dollars during the next seven years. Owners of Perkins engines, which are widely supported around the world, would not have to go to the extremes as we did—which included carrying a fully refurbished spare cylinder head (complete with lapped in valves)—but it is smart to have spare “consumables” like belts and hoses no matter what type of boat you have.

Upon returning from his circumnavigation, former PS Editor Nick Nicholson (no relation), put together his recommendation for spares. I’ve taken some of my own suggestions and added them to his below. I would encourage reading Nick’s full article “Offshore Log: Engine Spares for Cruising.”

Fuel Filters

We had a Dahl fuel filter, most other boats had Racor. We found fuel filter elements all over the world, but getting the quantity and micron rating we needed was no guarantee. Remember you have at least two filters: a remote primary filter between the tank and the engine, and a factory-installed secondary filter on the engine itself. The secondary filter is typically more difficult to find. Off-brand filters are available, but I hesitate to recommend these, especially for the secondary filter, since using the wrong micron-rating can ruin your fuel injectors or injection pump. If you resort to an off-brand filter, be absolutely positive you are getting an identical match. For prolonged cruising, you can't go wrong by carrying a dozen of each filter. A load of contaminated fuel can quickly wipe out your supply of spares.

Fuel Injectors

Recommended service intervals for fuel injectors vary by manufacturer, but fuel contamination and carbon build-up is such a common problem that many cruising sailors carry at least one spare injector. If you carry a full set (not cheap) you can still operate your boat while your injectors are being cleaned and serviced. (In the Caribbean, we mailed ours back to the U.S. for servicing). Some crusing sailors even carry a spare injection pump—a relatively expensive item. I never met any cruisers who serviced their own injectors, but below is an interesting video describing a do-it-yourself injector cleaning kit, and how to recognize a proper spray pattern (something we could do in situ with our old hand-cranked Volvo). Note the surprisingly high rate of injector failure among old diesel cars. I don't have any experience with the Monark injector nozzles the technician in the video describes, but they sound like they are worth looking into.

Engine Oil

If you're picky about engine oil—and you should be—you may find your favorite oil in some countries. Sometimes it is available under a different name, and with a little research you might sort this out. Generally speaking, you'll be able to find diesel engine oil with the specified American Petroleum Institute (API) certification or its equivalent almost everywhere you can buy fuel. For long-term cruising, carry a minimum for six changes, or about 600 hours of engine operation.

Oil Filters

Oil filters are another issue. There are so many varieties of oil filters in the world that it pays to do a little research. In Vanuatu, we found Napa filters that were identical to our Volvo filters but cost much less, but, again, if you go this route you want to be sure you are getting the right filter. When you do find the right filters, buy them. They're a lot harder to find than engine oil. These filters tend to corrode, even if they are sealed in plastic, so stow them with some silicone beads in a water-tight box.

Nick reported ended up with a whole case of defective Fram filters he had bought in New Zealand, so it is a good idea to check one from a new batch right away to make sure it is working properly.

Belts

You’ll need spare V-belts for you alternator, particularly if it’s the high-output type.  It is almost impossible to judge the quality of a V-belt just by looking, and once you leave the US, it's harder to find the industrial-rated V-belts that you need for high-output alternators. Most belts you find overseas are fractional-horsepower automotive belts that won’t last long driving a 100-amp alternator, even if you have a dual-belt-drive system (highly recommended high output alternators).

Replace a belt the instant it starts showing sidewall wear or cracking. As a rule, belts for high-output alternators, which have small pulleys in order to increase output, should be replaced every 500 hours of engine operation. Belts driving large pulleys, such as those on refrigeration compressors, will last much longer. Belts are relatively inexpensive, they keep well, and are easy to stow. Leave home with as many as you think you will need for the length of your cruise. Replaced belts that still have some life can serve as spares; just be sure to mark them as “used.” 

Alternators

Alternators have a relatively high rate of failure, but a repair is often as simple as replacing the brushes. Most cruisers replace factory-supplied alternators with high-output models, saving the original factory alternator as a spare. This may sound fine in theory, but swapping between different types of alternator may require changes in alignment, belt length, or even voltage regulation systems. Most stock alternators are internally regulated, while virtually all high-output alternators are externally regulated. To avoid hassles, you can carry at least one spare, identical, high-output alternator, as well as a rebuild kit. We went through one Hitachi alternator and I rebuilt two others. Nick carried three identical Balmar alternators, and used every single one of them. Even if you have nominally identical alternators, pre-fit each one to make sure that there are no installation glitches, and that you understand the process of changing them completely.

Gearbox

Probably the most neglected part of the drive train is the gearbox. Gearbox fluid does not last forever, but how often should you change it? Some engine owner's manuals don’t even give replacement intervals. Mechanics Nick spoke with said the oil in a common two-shaft gearbox, such as the Hurth, should be changed at least at every other engine oil change, or 200 hours of operation. Make sure you know what type of fluid your gearbox uses—it may be engine oil, automatic transmission fluid, or something else. Like every other consumable, carry enough for at least a year of service.

Water Pumps

Probably our biggest headache was the Volvo’s raw water pump, an expensive bronze-body model made by Johnson. The raw-water pump impellors and seals generally held up well, but sediment in the water would cause the shaft to wear. If left to its own, this could allow water into the crankcase, precipitating a series of unfortunate (and expensive) events. In shallow silty waters like river basins, this failure, indicated by a tell-tale drip from a weep hole the pump body, might come on relatively suddenly. Once the shaft is worn, a simple seal replacement won’t work. By the end of our cruise, we made sure we had at least five impellors, a dozen seals (two per change), and three spare pump shafts on board—this in addition to complete assembled pump. A quickly removable Speedseal can make rebuilds easy; although we didn’t have one. We found it cheaper to have the pump shafts precision made at a Singapore machine shop than to buy new ones from Volvo. (We did the same thing in Panama, lapping in an intake valve for a Volvo diesel truck that met almost the same specs.)

Although it may seem like a lot of work to actually do a dry-run pump change, you should at least check to make sure you know what is involved, what size wrenches will be needed, and what other bits and pieces may have to be removed in order to change pumps. These types of failures do not occur when you are sitting comfortably at anchor or in a marina.

This is just a preliminary list, but it covers the most common items. For a more detailed list of spares, check out Nigel Calder’s excellent book dedicated especially to marine diesels: “Marine Diesel Engines, Maintenance, Troubleshooting, and Repair.” We sometimes stock this book at our bookstore (which also carries Calder's "Boatowner's Mechanical and Electrical Manual"). But if it isn't there, its bound to be on Amazon.com.

Comments (8)

Who would put a fire extinguisher in the engine compartment. That is where the fire starts put outside of the engine compartment. Most of the time there is a hole in the cover that you can fog the compartment with the fire extinguisher to smother the fire.

Posted by: Mac-2 | May 10, 2018 11:06 PM    Report this comment

The brushes on an alternator do not carry the full output current but only the field current which is only about 5% of the rated output. The brushes in modern alternators are designed to last the lifetime of the alternator. More common failure items are the hard-working (read high operating temperature) rectifier assembly, the stator (where the output power is generated) and the bearings. High-output alternators are particularly susceptible to failure since doubling the output current results in quadrupling the heat generated internally. I recommend carrying a complete unit as a spare.

Posted by: elim | May 3, 2018 9:46 PM    Report this comment

There was a comment under alternators that you can replace brushes. It's my understanding that brushes were in the old generators which put out DC current. Alternators, in automobiles since 1963, put out AC current and that current is rectified into DC. What say you?

Posted by: Massis | May 3, 2018 12:00 PM    Report this comment

I would ad to that, hoses, clamps and a starter. Plus miscelaneous fasteners, nuts bolts screws etc.

Posted by: Eric T | January 30, 2015 9:08 AM    Report this comment

Don't overlook the small details.
The clamps holding the raw water pump on my new engine used slot head machine screws. Mounted over a very deep bilge on my boat. Dropping one of these into the bilge renders the whole engine inoperable.

I replaced these, and the pump cover plate machine screws, with Allen head machine screws. Much less likely to slip and drop off the Allen wrench. Much easier to hand tighten as the head is taller and knurled. And much easier to hold onto the machine screw onto the Allen wrench to remove or to insert and begin installation.

An inexpensive and practical upgrade. Plus a full set of spares.

Posted by: Raandly W | January 29, 2015 10:25 PM    Report this comment

For those of us with old Volvo's, I am told that many have converted to an electric water pump, or carry one as a spare. I still use the original and have only had to replace the seals once from weeping water.

Instead I have gone the backup route and carry an 85lb, 10 hp for my dinghy, which also mounts on my boat. Slow but good in a pinch. And beats towing!

Posted by: George M | January 29, 2015 10:51 AM    Report this comment

The blessing--and the curse--of twin engines is that you can always get there on the other engine, although things break twice as often. And while you can get there on one engine, the low speed maneuverability (docking, anchoring) is pitiful; all the boat wants to do is go in circles. The result is carrying few or no parts for serious problems and more parts for common and easily repaired faults, as well as making certain that the fuel and electrical systems are separated.

Posted by: Drew Frye | January 29, 2015 8:15 AM    Report this comment

Given the trend toward emissions-free propulsion (electric cars, etc) what is on the horizon with respect to engine and battery systems that can be recharged with a combination of solar and wind power? Maybe if one is sailing in the first place one of the reasons for this happy choice is to leave the noise and smoke behind as much as possible. With big advances in electric cars and new battery technologies, plus improvements in solar panel and wind harnessing technology, we can't be that far off from an emissions-free future in cruising.

Posted by: anatman | January 28, 2015 2:02 PM    Report this comment

New to Practical Sailor?
Register for Free!

Already Registered?
Log In