Searching for Spray Shine

Testers put 14 spray-on waxes through their paces.

6

Is there a quick, easy way to get a glossy shine on the deck and topsides between the grueling wax-and-buff efforts? To find out, testers launched a search for affordable spray waxes-liquid waxes designed for speedy touchups rather than full-tilt compounding-and-waxing jobs.

Wax Sprays

We specifically sought out spray-on products that offer a glossy finish and some surface protection and that are applied after rubbing compounds, fillers, waxes, and polishes. We evaluated products intended to help maintain hulls, cockpits, and topsides that are in good shape-not hulls that are badly oxidized or need more TLC than a spit polish. (If oxidation has started, you will need a rubbing compound; see the April 2014 issue online.) Think of spray waxes as detailers for surfaces-similar to the way Pledge is used as a furniture surface detailer.

In the past, weve evaluated paste waxes (see PS, February 2009 online), which are hard waxes normally sold in cans and tubs, and liquid waxes and polishes (see PS, July 2009 online). For this report, we looked at 14 spray waxes marketed for car, boat, or RV use that claimed to provide a high gloss.

Wax Sprays

Wax vs. Polish

The terms polish and wax are not necessarily interchangeable, and manufacturers have distinct definitions for each. In general, polishes combine fine powders, such as clay, with chemicals that react with a surface (gelcoat or paint), for a lasting, shiny effect. A wax, either natural or synthetic, provides a more temporary coating to give the surface a glossy shine.

A good natural wax will crystallize and provide a glossy finish from the heat generated from buffing and rubbing. As any boat owner knows, buffing is hard, time-consuming work. When the waxed surface is exposed to the sun and saltwater spray, the shine may last only a few months. Carnauba wax, a wax taken from the leaves of the Brazil-grown Carnauba palm, is the hardest natural wax, and it tolerates heat fairly well. Along with its use in vehicle polishes, Carnauba wax is used in lipsticks and on the surface of products like records, apples, and cucumbers. The newer, synthetic polymer waxes don't require as much rubbing as natural waxes, and some last much longer than the natural ones. Some product formulas combine the two.

When choosing a wax, remember that a formula high in Carnauba may be best for a short-term brilliant shine, but one that provides a hard, glass-like coating and resists UV will likely have the best long-term protection.

Wax Sprays

What we tested

This test field featured 14 liquid spray-on waxes labeled spray wax, quick wax, speed wax, speed detailer, or easy shine and protectant. They claimed to provide a quick, easy way to clean, shine, and protect. These spray-bottle waxes are designed to be touch-up waxes that remove surface dirt, dust, smudges, fingerprints, and water spots, and help surfaces maintain an existing luster. While some offer great results, don't expect the shine to last more than a month or two.

Some of the test products use additives to protect against UV rays, while other formulas include Carnauba wax or PTFE (PolyTetraFlouroEthylene, also known as Teflon) for shine and protection.

The Sudbury Miracle Coat with PTFE was the only one we tested that included both. Six of the test products include Carnauba wax: 3Ms Marine Clean and Shine Wax, Flitz Waxx Speed Wax, Turtle Wax Express Shine, Turtle Wax Ice Premium Care, Eagle One Superior Nanowax, and Surf City Garage Barrier Reef Spray Wax. Two advertise using PTFE for shine, Star brite Boat Guard Speed Detailer and Protectant and Star brite Ultimate Water Spot Remover. Five use other additives in their formulations: 303 Marine Speed Detailer (3020), Meguiars Quick Wax No. 59, ArmorAll Ultra Shine Protectant, Mothers California Gold, and NuFinish Rapid Shine Foam Detailer.

Turtle Wax Ice Premium Spray Wax

All were advertised or recommended for boat, RV, and car applications to clean and maintain a high-gloss finish on fiberglass and other surfaces. All are available at marine chandleries, big box stores, or automotive stores. The Sudbury wax can be purchased from the maker online.

Wax Sprays

How We Tested

To test the spray waxes, we applied each one to a taped-off section of an old, white fiberglass hatch cover, and then we left the panel exposed to the weather for 30 days.

Testers prepped the test panel by washing it with West Marine Degreaser and machine buffing it with Meguiars No. 91 professional-grade Power Cut rubbing compound (PS Best Choice, April 2014) to remove dirt and scratches. Testers then applied a coat of NuFinish paste wax, an easy-on, easy-off paste wax that rated highly in PSs tests as a good, inexpensive polish with long-term protection. Each spray wax was applied according to maker instructions and then polished by hand with microfiber towels.

We applied one coat of each test wax to each test area. The applied products faced a series of bench tests immediately after application, and again after a month of weathering atop our Sarasota, Fla., workshop, in the hot sun and heavy rain. To gauge coating integrity and rate water repellency, each section was misted with water and the water-beading ability was rated. The gloss test was carried out in a darkened room, where we aimed an LED flashlight at each test section and rated the degree of clarity of the reflected light. All ratings are relative to the field at that test time.

In general, the instructions on the spray waxes were all the same: 1. Shake well. 2. Spray on a small area. 3. Rub in with a clean cloth. 4. When dry, using a second, clean, microfiber towel, lightly buff to a shine. All detailers emphasize using clean cloths and changing cloths often. The new microfiber rags work well because they easily slough off dust, dirt, and wax powder.

Since all of the spray waxes emphasized how quick and easy they are to use, testers noted any that were more labor intensive. Our ease of application rating covers both how easily the wax goes on and how easily it polishes off to produce a shine. The instructions on several product bottles make the point that they can be sprayed on when the boat is wet, encouraging their use after a washdown. While polish is intended for a once-a-year application, spray waxes should be used once a month to keep the shine and protection going.

It should be noted that our hatch cover test panel has seen a few years in the sun, and its surface is far from a new boat finish. Also, it is white and does not show spots and smudges as much as a colored gelcoat would. For our next test, we are looking for a new or well-maintained, dark-hulled boat, such as a Hinckley.

The test panels will remain mounted on the roof of our workshop for a few more months, so we can evaluate their durability.

Wax Sprays

What We Found

Most of the test products did a good job of producing an initial gloss, but after 30 days in the near-tropical sun and rain, several test sections had noticeably lost their shine and water-beading ability, although testers found that all of the sections were equally easy to clean.

Overall, the standout on both the water-beading and gloss tests was Turtle Waxs Ice Premium Care, with Sudbury Miracle Coat and NuFinish Rapid Shine performing nearly as well. Turtle Wax claims the Ice Premium is the most advanced synthetic formula ever developed for maximum shine and protection. It combines natural Carnauba wax with hydrophobic resin polymer technology, creating a bond with non-porous surfaces for a longer-lasting protection. It also contains an adhesion promoter to help hold the wax and water-resistant polymers on any hard surface. Well have to see how the coating holds up, but for now, we can say this formula works.

Turtle Wax Ice- which is also one of the least expensive sprays tested (bonus)- earned our Best Choice pick.

Testers reported that the Sudbury Miracle Coat, which was launched in the summer of 2014, went on easily and wiped off quickly, leaving a nice shine. It is a Recommended product, as is the NuFinish Rapid Shine Foam Detailer, a detailer product for touch-ups, includes silicon emulsifiers for long-lasting shine. After 30 days, it was still beading water well and had a Good gloss.

Other spray waxes that showed fair performance include Mothers California Gold, as well as the water-based 3M Marine Clean and Shine Wax and Flitz Speed Wax, which also are Carnauba products.

The Mothers can work as a booster over an existing wax, as a stand-alone, or to maintain high-use areas. Its test performance was above average, and it was one of the least expensive products tested. It earns our Budget Buy pick. Mothers also sells a Marine Spray Wax speed detailer, which should deliver the same results; as far as we can tell, it has the same formula as the spray we tested..

Flitzs Speed Wax claims a super-fast, deep shine with protection that lasts up to three months, but the test section was already losing its luster after 30 days, earning a Fair for gloss.

Two of the more disappointing test results were from Eagle One and ArmorAll, which both notched Fair and Poor ratings for gloss. Eagle One Superior Nanowax uses nano-sized Carnauba particles to fill scratches and provide shine and water repellency. The ArmorAll Ultra Shine, however, does not contain Carnauba or other wax, but it does have UV blockers, a hardener, and silicone for shine.

Conclusion

Based on test results immediately after application and again after 30 days, we could not say definitively that one category of spray wax was obviously better than the other. The top performers were fairly evenly divided between synthetic waxes and those advertised as containing carnauba. These spray-and-wipe products will make a boat detailers job easier, but unless youre showing or selling your boat, the normal wax routine is sufficient to protect your gelcoat. Well keep an open mind though, and continue to use the top finishers. If we find anything worth reporting, well let you know.

Spray Waxes
Darrell Nicholson, editor of Practical Sailor, grew up boating on Miami’s Biscayne Bay on everything from prams to Morgan ketches. Two years out of Emory University, after a brief stint as a sportswriter, he set out from Miami aboard a 60-year-old wooden William Atkin ketch named Tosca. For 10 years, he and writer-photographer Theresa Gibbons explored the Caribbean, crossed the Pacific, and cruised Southeast Asia aboard Tosca, working along the way as journalists and documenting their adventures for various travel and sailing publications, including Cruising World, Sail, Sailing, Cruising Helmsman, and Sailing World. Upon his return to land life, Darrell became the associate editor, then senior editor at Cruising World magazine, where he worked for five years. Before taking on the editor’s position at Practical Sailor, Darrell was the editor of Offshore magazine, a boating-lifestyle magazine serving the New England area. Darrell has won multiple awards from Boating Writer’s International, including the Monk Farnham award for editorial excellence. He holds a U.S. Coast Guard 100-ton Master license and has worked as a harbor pilot and skippered a variety of commercial charter boats.

6 COMMENTS

  1. You should seriously consider the Zep floor care process, cleaner, stripper then high traffic floor polish. It works wonderfully for me and is used by many RV owners. Especially good for older boats whose gel-coat is beyond polishing. Even better than using it on fiberglass, I use to polish the interior wood on my 1973 Alberg 30. The polish dries to a hard finish so it never attracts or collects dust and it protects the wood.

  2. “Turtle Wax Ice- which is also one of the least expensive sprays tested (bonus)- earned our Best Choice pick.”

    Really?? Amazon.ca is $43 not $10.99. The largest auto parts retailer in Canada does not even offer the product. So adding price and availability to the assessment “Ice” is off the radar. $20 (Canadian) for this amount of spray cleaner gets several comparable products.

    Practical Sailor ” a swing and a miss”.

    • Brian, I just found Amazon.com listing Turtle Wax T477R Ice Premium Spray Wax – 20 oz.at $8.24.
      So, you might want to look again. As Amazon lists identical products from many different suppliers, it’s not unusual to find an outrageously high price, leading one to wonder if it occurs from malfeasance or an honest ommision of the quantity (e.g. price per case).

  3. Shame you didn’t have a control panel with no spray shine. With that you could determine if they had any advantage or even degraded the NuFinish paste wax substrate.

    We have been using wash wax all washwax.com. Would have been nice to see how it did in the lineup. Maybe next time. Can’t say it is the best spray shine but it works well as a waterless wash for the RV.

    Assuming the products didn’t degrade the NuFinish, a fair beading after only 30 days is a pretty poor showing for NuFinish paste wax as well as the spray shine.

  4. I wonder if anyone has ever tried Pledge. I have not on a boat. However I have a friend who was an over the road truck driver and he used it on his truck. I think that would be a fairly rough test. After he told me this I happened to buy a truck and used it. The shine was the only good thing about that truck .

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here