Compact Scuba Kits for Sailors

Mini SCUBA Kits Can Save Your Skin

9

In general, many cruisers prefer the freedom of snorkeling to scuba diving, yet there are situations when extending the time you can spend underwater becomes a safety issue.

Scuba gear is useful for clearing a fouled prop, freeing stuck anchors, replacing zinc anodes, making underwater repairs, and of course, sightseeing, however, it is heavy and cumbersome, particularly if one is working in the vicinity of the prop or rudder in any kind of a seaway.

Hookah-type alternatives to scuba such as SNUBA, Brownies Third Lung are an option but you are then tethered by and at times limited by the length of the air hose.

Another alternative is using a small or ultra-small scuba tank which offers autonomy and freedom.

Several years ago I decided to eliminate my scuba tank which was stowed under the V-berth, in order to make room and save weight for the installation of a bow thruster. In a dive shop I found Spare Air, a very small scuba tank and regulator sold as an emergency back-up for scuba divers. Of the two sizes available, the larger (3.0 cu. ft., $320) is preferable. It comes with an adapter allowing it to be filled in 45-60 seconds from a scuba tank. As I no longer have a larger tank aboard to fill the Spare Air from, I have it filled in dive shops. About half the time, the shops have refused payment for such a small amount of air, and the other half have charged $10 or less.

The amount of floating lines plus cargo and fishing nets on the worlds oceans is alarming. During one Atlantic crossing we had to heave-to and get into the water four times to untangle nets and lines from our rudder and prop. Usually I can hold my breath long enough to clear the prop or rudder, but there have been several times when Ive needed to use my Spare Air.

A few years ago in Fiji, changing wind and currents caused our anchor chain to shift from the sandy area where wed dropped the anchor to instead become wrapped around a mushroom-shaped coral head. With excellent water clarity in the 70-foot depth, I snorkeled over the anchor and directed our helmsperson to let out a little more chain and slowly motor around to unwind the chain. This only caused the chain to become more tangled. Using the Spare Air, I pulled myself hand-over hand down the chain, physically lifted the chain free of the coral head and just made it back to the surface. This was only time I wished the Spare Air had a little more capacity.

At recent boat shows Ive seen the very impressive package that Mantus (same company that makes the anchors) is selling containing a 13 cu. ft. aluminum tank, backpack, regulator, and spare regulator all in a compact, waterproof storage backpack for $600. The advantage of this package is four times the air capacity giving 15 – 20 minutes of working time at 30 feet, but the drawback is a little more bulk and weight; 15pounds vs. 2 pounds for the Spare Air.

Ocean racers take note: Following the death of Andrew Simpson when the Swedish catamaran capsized in the last Americas Cup, crew members started carrying Spare Air as part of their safety gear. If dealing with escape from a capsized boat (monohull or multihull), Spare Air could prove useful.

It is essential that anyone using a compressed air cylinder underwater first completes a dive course. Holding ones breath while ascending after having breathed compressed air can be fatal, even when coming up from relatively shallow depths. Any scuba tank (including Spare Air) needs annual visual inspections and a hydrostatic test every five years.

Practical Sailor has been independently testing and reporting on marine products for serious sailors for more than 45 years. Supported entirely by subscribers, Practical Sailor accepts no advertising or any form of compensation from manufacturers whose products we test. Testing is carried out by a team of experts from a wide range of fields including marine electronics, marine safety, marine surveying, sailboat rigging, sailmaking, engineering, ocean sailing, sailboat racing, and sailboat construction and design. This diversity of expertise allows us to carry out in-depth, objective evaluation of virtually every product available to serious sailors. Practical Sailor is edited by Darrell Nicholson, a long-time liveaboard sailor and trans-Pacific cruiser with more than three decades of experience as a marine writer, photographer, boat captain, and product tester. Before taking on the editor’s position at Practical Sailor, Darrell was the editor of Offshore magazine, a boating-lifestyle magazine serving the New England area. Darrell has won multiple awards from Boating Writer’s International, including the Monk Farnham award for editorial excellence. He holds a U.S. Coast Guard 100-ton Master license and has worked as a harbor pilot and skippered a variety of commercial charter boats.

9 COMMENTS

    • Have you used the SKORKL? I’m curious, but a little skeptical about it. I’m not a fan of their marketing. They make it look too casual, like using a snorkel, but if you aren’t familiar with breathing compressed air it can be very dangerous.

    • This was reviewed in some magazine recently and was generally thought to be somewhere between a rip-off and a hoax! You would need to pump for about an hour full out to get the pressure up enough for about 5 min. Of air. If you fill with compressor, it is about same as spare air, but less reliable quality, and more expensive, and still need scuba training.

      • I’ve got the Scorkl kit (actually 2 tanks) and used it. It is fantastic. You are right, it takes a while to pump to the higher pressures but not impossible and it gives 100% independence. Thoroughly recommend.

  1. SpareAir as well as Mantus’setup look pretty interesting…think we are gonna check them both out! Ecsepcially since we have Copper cost now and only need to go down for 20 minutes instead of 2.5 hours!

  2. I just purchased the Mantus backpack and tank. I have a lot of extra scuba gear laying around since I have upgraded my gear a couple of times. I plan to keep this on the boat for emergency use. I almost always have full scuba gear aboard, but the Mantus setup should be much quicker and easier to get into.

  3. For those with a Scuba card who dive without frequent access to a dive shop, I’d like to find a 12vdc, 24vdc, or 110vac compact dive tank compressor that could fill said tank over time. Is there a reasonably affordable such unit anywhere?

  4. I’m a former Scuba instructor and find as a sailor the Mantus is the way to go. Just right for small boat tasks – not enough for diving, but that’s not it’s purpose. Also have a Spare Air, but it was designed only as an emergency backup and not much else. The Mantus is compact and a practical accessory. Great to have aboard.

  5. I dive in cold northern coast waters. We need warm wet or dry suits. Discussed with a dive buddy and we wondered if this might be a challenge, even with the extra air of the Mantus.
    Also, what fitting is on the Mantus and reg.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here